By an additional accidental alignment of the stars, I had scored a ticket seven months ago to what turned out to be Dorothée Gilbert’s penultimate performance with the Paris Opera Ballet before her formal “adieux” would take place on October 15th. So here I was on the 12th.
Don’t kill me, but it took me a while to warm up to Dorothée Gilbert ever since my eye had caught her in Les Deux Pigeons when she was still a student. Max Factor orange and baby pudding feet even back then couldn’t belie her steel will to get out there on stage. It was like watching a young Joan Crawford claim her territory, just not in black and white.
In her early days with the company, Gilbert was so focused on crafting her own kind of perfection that when I saw a good number of her Fille mal gardées with Nicolas Le Riche (the number due to buying blind) she danced them exactly to the letter and so perfectly the same way each time it almost scared me. This young’un’s ferociously studious approach was not letting her evident charisma come to the fore. But oh, those balances!
Then Gilbert got paired with Hugo Marchand – in, yes, Manon — around ten years ago. They just clicked into place at first glance and ever since then Gilbert has relaxed and blossomed into the performer we are now so sad to let go. She no longer wastes even one split second concentrating on technical perfection. It’s there to the point that both she and the audience don’t worry about it at all. It’s a given. As with Joan Crawford, her performances have become both reliable and extravagant.
But what I mean by technical perfection is not “x-pirouettes” or “x-degree leg lifts.” What I mean is more about how the body is simply in the right place at the right time doing the right thing that will advance the plot. Gilbert’s body has always reminded me of a voice. Think back to those opera singers who sang with careful perfect placement and then, at one stage in their careers, “boom!” suddenly found the voice that gives you chills.
******
************
So on October 12th, Dorothée Gilbert and Hugo Marchand gave the audience all that we could have ever wanted (and have come to expect). But at this point is there anything left to say about their partnership that hasn’t been said? The “fit” of their very different physiques, their instinctive – synchronic and seamless — reactions to shifts in the moods in the music? Their utter lack of hesitation nor of a wisp of that carefulness that can dull a crescendo? If Marchand lofted Gilbert any higher in the lifts she’d just keep floating up and when he swoops her down it feels like an idea he’s just cooked up. All this we know and what I saw was exactly what I expected. I think maybe some of us in the audience have been spoiled for too long…
Enter Manon. She has gazed around the square, locked eyes with Des Grieux, and then submitted trustingly to her brother’s care, even if she found that all these strangers patting and stroking her was getting to be a bit much.
Once this Manon and Des Grieux are left alone, well, the pas begins in playful sensuality (very cute, the way she makes him twirl). Their mutual admiration reads up until the top of the house. His solo is “I know this is it.” I have come to expect to delight in Marchand for his deliciously high opened-hip, balanced, yet “lean into your partner” arabesques à la Anthony Dowell. I was not disappointed. He did tons of them, and each time they were indeed an expression of what his avatar was thinking
In the First Act, Thomas Doquir as Lescaut pulls his standing hip backwards when he does tours à la seconde. He manages to achieve them, but if he just stood up against the movement and pushed his standing hip a bit forward they’d look bigger. When he pops in again after the first Bedroom scene, Gilbert’s Manon by now knows that her dear brother is trouble. Yet she lets herself be manipulated and Doquir revisits his multiple turns as Rothbart. Gilbert’s Manon, eyes wide shut to her rich suitor’s foot fetish, says goodbye to the bed and a true love she really wanted. Oh, we all make mistakes along the way.
This stubborn inability to make the right choices for herself Is indeed visible to the audience. Her own analysis saying exactly this unfortunately popped up in an online interview, so now my judgement feels clouded. Or confirmed.
Bianca Scudamore’s flirty, feminine, joyous, sprightly, Mistress was the big surprise after a string of dutiful performances in other ballets recently. She danced big, with light and high élan. All this, while sharing the stage with an étoile who is practically a national monument at this point, takes balls.
I was now enormously curious to know what Scudamore would do when she took on the lead role soon after, but of course I couldn’t find a ticket.
In Act Two’s glittery black dress, Gilbert’s refusal to engage Marchand’s eye meant a lot. Scudamore, not trying to upstage anyone, had a “come on, let’s make all the guys pay attention” energy. Scudamore and Doquir’s Drunken Duet became quite funny this time around. She did a ZsaZsa while Doquir circled around her, dead serious, trying desperately not to admit to himself that he was beyond high.
Gilbert, during her solo and then when she gets passed around from man to man in the air, gave the audience the sight of how a thin veneer of ice can slowly begin to crack. What struck me was her blind confidence in all her partners as she was thrust round and about. Her trust in everyone and anyone as both dancer and character helped you understand why she was heedlessly running head-first into danger.
In the last act, Gilbert is not afraid of anything, not even the jailor. Her only enemy had been herself in the first place. There was such energy in her fatal exhaustion. She fought back against the jailor, against fate, against death. I was torn between thinking about how beautifully she kept struggling to get back on her toes and desperately trying not to think about this and just surrender to the moment. Even if this wasn’t her last performance, knowing it was my last time still distracted me. Half of me wanted to analyze every detail of this Gilbert/Marchand, half of me wanted to forget about “Gilbert/Marchand” and just live the experience.
Spartacus (Sergei Bobrov). Photography courtesy of Varna International Ballet
I must admit that I have had a particular inability to take anything “Roman gladiator” seriously ever since that Saturday morning when Bugs Bunny encountered a Martian decked out in full Spartan gear, replete with scrub-brush-topped helmet, on my parents’ old TV. That goes for films as well as for ballet. So, what was I thinking as the Varna State Opera Ballet company’s Spartacus was about to begin? Uh oh.
But the desire to giggle quickly faded as I got swept up in an unusually lively and absorbing piece of total theater. On the night of July 17th in Bulgaria, Sergey Bobrov’s intelligent and subtle rethinking of an old, and odd, ballet finally convinced me that Spartacus may not be such a bad subject for a ballet after all.
While this choreographer’s training is rooted in Soviet-era hyper-athleticism and the explosive Moiseyev school of folk-dance, he gives them new verve and focus. His intelligent mélange — to which he has added a verismo approach to stage fighting, an incredibly complex vision of partnering, as well as a refreshing rejection of the old-fashioned hero/villain paradigm – serves to create a tightly narrated and endlessly inventive ballet that sweeps us along through two swift acts. The minutes of music cut from Khachaturian’s original 1954 score? I didn’t miss them at all.
This is the first time I’ve ever sat through a Spartacus with neither a sigh nor a yawn.
Bobrov is abetted in his endeavor by a vigorous company of polished dancers who share such a coherent style that you cannot tell which ones were trained in Europe or South America rather than Russia. My admiration for them only increased when, during an unexpectedly long intermission, the audience learned that during the entire first act the stage floor had been slick with condensed water due to a freak climate event. I mean, as wet as in “I just dumped three buckets on the floor.” (This would continue to be the case during Act Two, despite the heroic efforts of the cleaning crew). These kids were risking their necks, but no one out in the audience saw anything other than a committed and absorbing performance. The choreography, the narration, was that strong.
Historical Context:
The saga of the Third Servile War that ended in a bloodbath in 71 BCE, as later recounted by Plutarch and Appian, is fairly straightforward. Spartacus, a proud Thracian reduced to the status of slave-gladiator, instigates a small revolt which ultimately swells into an improvised army of around 70,000 angry men. The Romans are gob-smacked. It is noted he has a wife. His nemesis is praetor Marcus Licinius Crassus, an ambitious and brutal general, future consul of Rome. These two men have good reasons for wanting to kill each other. Although he outsmarts and outfights the Romans numerous times, to the point of almost taking out Crassus himself, in the end Spartacus was certainly killed. His body was never found; we only know that 6,000 of his followers – which included anyone from household slaves to fellow gladiators to shepherds who had just had enough – ended up crucified and left to rot all the way down the Via Appia.
History of Ballet Context:
Aram Khachaturian had composed a quite catchy Lenin-Prize winning ballet score in 1954. The subject was a clever choice, given that Spartacus had been one of Marx’s great heroes in the history of class struggles. It would be first choreographed by Leonid Jacobson for the Bolshoi in 1956. But Jacobson’s Fokine-correct abandonment of pointe shoes in the service of realism was not appreciated. Then Igor Moiseyev tried his hand at one in 1958. Ten years later Yuri Grigorovich and the Hungarian László Seregi simultaneously produced their own still-performed readings, both of which I have seen on stage.
When I first saw the Grigorovich version of Spartacus as a teenager during a Bolshoi tour to New York, I was perfectly aware that this tale of a doomed slave uprising in Ancient Rome was a piece of Agitprop, created by a man of his time and place. But I was willing to give it try.
The many things I remember I disliked about his ballet were confirmed during a Bolshoi tour to Paris in 2008: its Manichaeism; its reductive politics (it should not take three hours to illustrate the existence of slave/master and proletariat/bourgeois). Its extreme gendering also really got up the nose of this feminist: there was a muchness of manly men, and then there were “ze vimin,” also either good [wailing females in chiffon waving their arms about] or just bad [scheming hetaerae stabbing their pointe shoes into the floor]. Overly aestheticized and stylized stage battles and the etcetera of what has long come to be known as “Soviet Style Acrobatics” left me cold. It was loooong .
Seregi’s version for the Budapest Ballet seemed mildly less didactic, softer, with more focus on private drama. What I vaguely remember (it’s been a few decades) is that the subtext was an easy read: “the Russians now do unto Czechs and Hungarians as the Romans once did to their colonial subjects”.
Spartacus (Sergei Bobrov). Photography courtesy of Varna International Ballet
Good Guys/Bad Guys
One of my problems with the Grigorovich had been the paucity of vocabulary, and even how absolutely every turn or combination got done to the right.
Spartacus? A lot of head-clutching and splayed-finger angst, plus superfast chainés or rabid pirouettes to signal torment. A steady dose of grands jetés: regular, scissored, en tournant. Another problem was that Crassus the Roman General’s vocabulary didn’t differ all that much from Spartacus’s, down to the fist-clenching, the pop-out jumps, and those explosive folk-dance leaps where arms, legs and torso all arch backwards.
In Bobrov’s new Spartacus – despite the use of a full dose of classic acrobatics and heroic bouncing around — the immense inventiveness he brings to combinations means that the choreography – even when those vehement pirouettes take off — never got predictable, boring, stale. Every character had their own vocabulary. Not once did I feel a dance was being done simply because thirty-six bars of music needed to be filled.
That new thrills that can happen onstage is rare, and I praise Bobrov’s pursuit of innovation. He keeps reimagining the classic flying configurations that we in the West have oohed and aahed about ever since our first look at “Spring Waters”. But he builds upon the potential of last-second catches and holds to the point that you no longer remember which way is up or down. The variety proved energizing. My notebook ended up full of question marks. What could these things possibly be called? Chair lifts? Lap lifts? Scoop lifts? Tumble lifts? Even when Spartacus ends up only dancing with a veil (attached to…I’m not telling), the fabric responds to him and seems to be dancing itself.
Spartacus (Sergei Bobrov). Photography courtesy of Varna International Ballet
The intently focused Danylo Motkov brought fascinatingly elegant stretch and bounce to his Spartacus along with a most welcome manly softness. He humanized this superhero from the moment he ripped off his gladiator’s mask. His Spartacus never veers off into the melodramatic even when repeatedly whipping off superfast pirouettes of grief or rage (yes that one, again) or when he launches into those arched leaps with knees bent back (or forward, or in between). Motkov is also a most skilled and considerate partner. Despite the use of spectacular, sometimes impossible-looking, lifts that get pushed skywards and sideways, Spartacus’s duets with his mate, here called Achillea [Phyrgia in other versions], each have a different kind of lyricism because they are anchored in an evolving narrative.
And here Crassus concentrates more on his lovers. This really helps push the narrative along and pulls this ballet back from the manosphere. His contemptuous hatred of Spartacus will explode to a whole other level after the gory demise of one of his lovers. He’s an antagonist, not a caricature of motiveless malevolence. Crisp and complex in the role of Crassus, Vladimir Mozgovoj is a peacock in public who lets his guard down in private. I should mention that all of Mozgovoj’s manèges with double tours en tournant positively sizzled.
You wanna fight?
Spartacus (Sergei Bobrov). Photography courtesy of Varna International Ballet
Whereas in the Grigorovich version, the group movements consisted of soldiers (or rebels) prancing side by side in formation, here the cohorts got de-aestheticized, and engaged with each other in what looked like actual combat. Despite the small size of the open-air stage in Varna, entrances and exits were planned to full effect. Dancers keep pouring in and out from three and more directions. Here the soldiers and gladiators really broke loose.
You could hear clanging of metal against metal throughout this ballet. The angle of swords ferociously planted “into” an opponent are so precisely calibrated that the action felt surprisingly real. The falls of the fallen were superbly untheatrical, heavy.
Bobrov succeeds at making that abstraction, “the people,” zing by specifically allotting certain steps to only one group or personage. For example, we know shepherds had joined Spartacus’s rebellion, but Grigorovich kind of blended them into generic crowd formations. Here the Shepherds hoist their crooks, root them around earthily during folkloric roundabouts, do awkward squats, and even inch out backwards from the wings in a stunningly inventive – as well as hilarious – bent over forwards conga line that any other choreographer who sees it will definitely want to steal.
The battles are not only full of surprises but always end with flair. Bobrov turns out to be a master of the tableau vivant that pays off both visually and dramatically. Just about every scene ends with a striking visual (which I would rather not divulge).
Ze Vimin
Spartacus (Sergei Bobrov). Photography courtesy of Varna International Ballet
The women in the older productions? Lots of passive bourrée-ing around and turned-in passés for the good women as they express. Wispy arms alternate with developés front/side/back and that’s about it. The bad women do splits and wiggle their shoulders while leaning back on their knees in that decadent gypsy dance manner. Duh.
In Bobrov’s choreography the female domestic slaves are kittenish and assertive in a manner straight out of Puss n’Boots. They have swing. But most of all, Bobrov finally gets at least half of the females out of the bedroom by introducing a most refreshing and welcome plot twist that is anchored in historical record. Did you know that the Ancients do mention that the powerful and dexterous cohort of gladiators included enslaved women? Therefore, here Spartacus is conjoined to an equal with a mind of her own, a fighter, rather than to a weeping willow. As Achillea, the valiant Natalia Bobrova shape shifts from strong as a rock to pliant as a vine in a split second. Always on the alert for the next challenge, she seems to not even sweat. I rooted more for her than for Spartacus, even. Her sword drawn once again, Achillea will even face off with Crassus himself and die like a man.
The several pas de deux for Crassus and his Persian concubine Roxana (the regal, alternately flirtatious and ferocious, Roberta Pereira) contrasted vividly with those of Achillea and Spartacus both in intent and in feeling: sharper, swifter, knottier. Roxana wrapped herself around the general like a…pretzel?…a boa constrictor? Their specific vocabulary included upside-down splitting that a brave and virtuous gladiatrix like Bobrova’s Achillea would find beneath contempt.
All the women in this Varna production bristled with confidence and determination. When Natalia Bobrova whipped out fouettés with both angry conviction and a sword in each hand during Act Two, the audience whooped at yet another demonstration of dancing machisma. [Amusingly, spell-check keeps insisting I revert to the masculine version of this word].
Spartacus (Sergei Bobrov). Photography courtesy of Varna International Ballet
Gaydar
We know the Romans where quite open to sexual adventure, especially when it came to the exploration of tasty younger males. More than that, the philosophers often spoke of true transformative love only taking place between men rather than between men and women.
Whether it’s in a ballet, movie, or comic book, the sight of buff sweaty bare-chested guys decked out in leather should set off at least some bells, don’t you think? No prior choreographer of Spartacus ever dared to address the obvious. I should add that this was not only due to Communist prudes: in Hollywood’s 1960 blockbuster, the scene where Crassus salaciously propositioned his male slave with the come-on “my taste includes both snails and oysters” swiftly landed on the cutting room floor.
Bobrov is the first ever to grab the bull by its horns, so to speak. He has added a fifth lead, and a clearly loud and proud one at that. Far from being a camp distraction, Azar the Persian Slave adds a most welcome dynamic to this tale of love and loss.
This role is clearly custom-made for the unique talents of the witty and double-jointed Vittorio Scole. His splits and hip swivels and 2 p.m. (aka way beyond 12 o’clock) extensions, plus his knowing sass, will be hard for someone else to replicate one day. His, um, “I’ll just use my own pole to amuse myself, thank you” solo, which made for a gleeful moment of respite from all the drama, was delightful.
Inserting an ambitious and endearingly flawed queen into the relationship between Crassus and that scheming dominatrix Roxana would serve, most of all, to further humanize the general. He’s clearly more at ease with Miss Thing than with the Agrippina wannabe. Crassus’s full-bodied reaction to Azar’s violent demise reinforced the ballet’s premise that no guy is ever a totally bad person. Life is not lived in black and white. It’s full of grey zones and blood-soaked reds.
Spartacus (Sergei Bobrov). Photography courtesy of Varna International Ballet
A ballet for our time?
Whether they speak truth to power or bend to power, works of art are always rooted a time and a place. The concluding scenes of all the theatrical incarnations of Spartacus demonstrate this. The last scenes of the Kirk Douglas Spartacus film, for example, paid wildly obvious homage to the solidarity of those who had refused to “name names” during the American Red Scare.
Grigorovich and Seregi (as I imagine Jacobson and Moiseyev, too) knew they had to provide uplifting finales. The people might lose this war, but the moral high ground soldiers on.
Bobrov’s finale? Nobody wins in the slightest. A mournful, abstract, and anti-heroic tableau turns out to have been inspired by the origin story of a flower we don’t even think about twice. Two gladiators (one probably Spartacus himself) had refused to fight to the death. They had instead thrust their swords into the ground, knowing that neither of them would be spared. In their place, the…gladiola sprouted. Did you know that this flower represents comradeship, solidarity, non-violence?
Women without men, sheathed in long black chiffon [thank goodness sparingly used in this production], pensively – at one point even angrily – dance with swords sheathed in that flower. When crossed mid-air, these instruments of death even form butterfly shapes, as if they want to fly away. But then they were pointed at us and loudly stabbed down into the floor of the stage. To hell with this never-ending violence!
Bobrov’s epic, slated to tour European venues next season, proves more than relevant given that great powers still feel they are entitled to abuse entire populations they deem inferior to them.
Therefore, it was most fitting to premiere this ballet in Spartacus’s homeland on the Black Sea, formerly known as Thrace, now called Bulgaria. As I wandered out to the beach the next morning, still mulling over the performance, I could not believe that I was only a stone’s throw away from more of mens’ pointless carnage.
Spartacus (Sergei Bobrov). Photography courtesy of Varna International Ballet
********************
*****************************
Spartacus in Varna : de retour dans la Comté
Spartacus (Sergei Bobrov). Photography courtesy of Varna International Ballet
Je dois avouer que j’ai du mal à prendre au sérieux tout ce qui touche aux gladiateurs romains depuis ce samedi matin où, sur le vieux téléviseur de mes parents, j’ai vu Bugs Bunny croiser un Martien en tenue complète de Spartiate, casque à crête inclus. Cela est aussi valable pour le cinéma que pour le ballet. Alors, quel était donc mon état d’esprit alors que « Spartacus » par le ballet de l’Opéra d’État de Varna allait débuter? Un certain scepticisme.
Mais l’envie de glousser s’est vite dissipée, balayée par une œuvre de « théâtre total » d’une vivacité et d’une force immersive rares. En ce 17 juillet, en Bulgarie, la relecture intelligente et subtile proposée par Sergey Bobrov de ce ballet ancien — et singulier — m’a finalement convaincu que « Spartacus » n’était peut-être pas, après tout, un si mauvais sujet de ballet.
Bien que la formation de ce chorégraphe soit ancrée dans l’hyper-athlétisme de l’ère soviétique ainsi que dans l’explosive tradition folklorique de l’école Moïsseïev, il insuffle à ces éléments une énergie et une rigueur nouvelles. Ce savant mélange — auquel s’ajoutent une approche réaliste des combats scéniques, une conception incroyablement complexe du travail de duo et un rejet rafraîchissant du schéma classique opposant héros et méchant — donne naissance à un ballet à la narration serrée et à l’inventivité inépuisable, qui nous emporte à travers deux actes au rythme soutenu. Quant aux minutes de musique supprimées de la partition originale de Khatchatourian (1954), elles ne m’ont absolument pas manqué.
C’est la première fois que j’assiste à « Spartacus » du début à la fin sans soupirer ni bâiller.
Bobrov est secondé dans son entreprise par une troupe vigoureuse aux danseurs accomplis ; ils partagent une telle cohérence stylistique qu’il est impossible de distinguer ceux qui ont été formés en Europe ou en Amérique du Sud de ceux qui l’ont été en Russie. Mon admiration pour eux n’a fait que croître lorsque, durant un entracte d’une durée inhabituelle, le public a appris que le sol de la scène avait été rendu glissant par de la condensation tout au long du premier acte, en raison d’un phénomène climatique exceptionnel. Je parle d’un sol si détrempé que si on y avait déversé trois seaux d’eau. La situation a perduré durant le deuxième acte, malgré les efforts héroïques de l’équipe de nettoyage. Ces jeunes artistes prenaient des risques considérables, mais personne dans la salle n’a rien perçu d’autre qu’une interprétation engagée et captivante tant la narration chorégraphique était forte.
Contexte historique :
La relation de la troisième guerre servile, qui s’acheva dans un bain de sang en 71 av. J.-C. et fut relatée plus tard par Plutarque et Appien, est assez simple. Spartacus, fier Thrace réduit au statut d’esclave-gladiateur, fomente une révolte qui finit par prendre de l’ampleur au point de former une armée de fortune d’environ 70 000 hommes en colère, stupéfiant les Romains. On sait qu’il a une épouse. Son grand rival est le préteur Marcus Licinius Crassus, général ambitieux et brutal, futur consul de Rome. Ces deux hommes ont de bonnes raisons de vouloir s’entretuer. Bien qu’il ait surpassé les Romains par la ruse et au combat à maintes reprises — manquant de peu d’éliminer Crassus lui-même —, Spartacus finira par trouver la mort. Son corps ne fut jamais retrouvé ; on sait seulement que 6 000 de ses partisans — un groupe hétéroclite allant des esclaves domestiques aux compagnons gladiateurs, en passant par des bergers à bout de patience — furent crucifiés et laissés à l’abandon le long de la Via Appia.
Contexte de l’histoire du ballet :
Aram Khatchatourian avait composé, en 1954, une partition de ballet très entraînante, récompensée par le prix Lénine. Le sujet était un choix judicieux, Spartacus figurant parmi les grands héros de Marx dans le cadre de la lutte des classes. L’œuvre fut d’abord chorégraphiée par Leonid Jacobson pour le Bolchoï en 1956. Toutefois, le choix de Jacobson d’abandonner les pointes au nom du réalisme — une démarche pourtant fidèle à l’esprit de Fokine — ne fut pas apprécié. Igor Moiseyev s’y essaya ensuite en 1958. Dix ans plus tard, Iouri Grigorovitch et le Hongrois László Seregi montèrent simultanément leurs propres versions, toujours à l’affiche aujourd’hui et que j’ai toutes deux vues sur scène.
Lorsque je découvris la version de « Spartacus » signée Grigorovitch alors que j’étais adolescente — lors d’une tournée du Bolchoï à New York —, j’étais parfaitement consciente que ce récit d’une révolte d’esclaves vouée à l’échec dans la Rome antique relevait de l’agitprop : œuvre d’un homme marqué par son époque et son milieu. J’étais néanmoins prêt à lui laisser sa chance.
Les nombreux aspects de son ballet qui m’avaient déplu ont été confirmés lors d’une tournée du Bolchoï à Paris en 2008 : son manichéisme; sa vision politique réductrice (il ne devrait pas falloir trois heures pour illustrer les oppositions binaires maître/esclave ou prolétariat/bourgeoisie). La manière dont les genres y étaient marqués à l’extrême a également beaucoup agacé la féministe que je suis : d’un côté, une profusion de messieurs très virils ; de l’autre, des dames, soit « bonnes » [femmes en mousseline gémissantes agitant les bras], soit « mauvaises » [courtisanes intrigantes plantant leurs pointes dans le sol]. Les combats scéniques enfin, excessivement esthétisés et stylisés, ainsi que tout l’arsenal de ce qu’on appelle depuis longtemps les « acrobaties de style soviétique », m’ont laissé de marbre. C’était… loooong.
La version de Seregi pour le Ballet de Budapest m’avait semblé un peu moins didactique, plus douce, et davantage centrée sur les drames intimes. Ce dont je me souviens vaguement (car c’était il y a quelques décennies), c’est que le sous-texte était limpide : « les Russes font désormais aux Tchèques et aux Hongrois ce que les Romains faisaient autrefois à leurs sujets colonisés ».
Spartacus (Sergei Bobrov). Photography courtesy of Varna International Ballet
Gentils contre méchants
L’un des problèmes que j’avais avec la version de Grigorovitch tenait également à la pauvreté du vocabulaire chorégraphique, et même au fait qu’absolument chaque tour ou chaque enchaînement était exécuté à droite.
Spartacus ? Beaucoup de gestes où l’on se prend la tête à deux mains et d’expressions d’angoisse avec les doigts écartés, sans oublier des déboulés ultra-rapides ou des pirouettes frénétiques pour traduire le tourment. Une dose constante de grands jetés : classiques, en ciseaux ou en tournant. L’autre problème était que le vocabulaire du général romain Crassus ne différait pas essentiellement de celui de Spartacus, jusque dans les poings serrés, les sauts explosifs et ces bonds inspirés de la danse folklorique où bras, jambes et buste se cambrent tous vers l’arrière.
Dans le nouveau « Spartacus » de Bobrov – malgré une bonne dose d’acrobaties classiques et de bonds héroïques –, l’immense inventivité déployée dans les combinaisons fait que la chorégraphie, même lorsque ces pirouettes impétueuses se déploient, ne devient jamais prévisible, ennuyeuse ou répétitive. Chaque personnage possède son propre vocabulaire gestuel. Pas une seule fois je n’ai eu l’impression qu’une danse était exécutée simplement pour combler trente-six mesures de musique.
Il est rare de vivre de telles sensations inédites sur scène, et je salue la quête d’innovation de Bobrov. Il réinvente sans cesse ces figures aériennes classiques qui, en Occident, nous ont émerveillés depuis notre première découverte de « Spring Waters ». Mais il exploite le potentiel des rattrapages et des portés de dernière seconde au point de nous faire perdre tout repère spatial. Cette variété s’est révélée stimulante. Mon carnet de notes a fini par se remplir de points d’interrogation. Comment nommer ces figures ? Portés chaise ? Portés sur les genoux ? Portés en cuillère ? Portés acrobatiques ? Même lorsque Spartacus danse uniquement avec un voile (attaché à… je n’en dirai pas plus), l’étoffe réagit à ses mouvements et semble danser d’elle-même.
Spartacus (Sergei Bobrov). Photography courtesy of Varna International Ballet
Danylo Motkov, d’une concentration absolue, a conféré à son Spartacus une élégance fascinante, faite d’extension et de ressort, tout en y apportant une douceur virile très bienvenue. Il a humanisé ce super-héros dès l’instant où il a arraché son masque de gladiateur. Son Spartacus ne sombre jamais dans le mélodrame, même lorsqu’il enchaîne à toute vitesse des pirouettes exprimant le deuil ou la rage (oui, encore elles), ou lorsqu’il se lance dans ces sauts en cambré, genoux pliés vers l’arrière (ou vers l’avant, ou dans une position intermédiaire). Motkov se révèle également être un partenaire extrêmement habile et attentionné. Malgré l’utilisation de portés spectaculaires – parfois d’apparence impensable – propulsés qu’ils sont vers le haut ou sur les côtés, les duos de Spartacus avec sa compagne, ici nommée Achillea [Phrygia dans d’autres versions], possèdent chacun un lyrisme singulier, car ils sont ancrés dans une narration en constante évolution.
Ici, Crassus se concentre davantage sur ses différents amants. Cela contribue réellement à faire avancer l’intrigue et permet au ballet d’échapper à une vision purement masculine et guerrière. Sa haine méprisante envers Spartacus atteindra un paroxysme après la mort sanglante de l’un de ses partenaires. C’est un antagoniste, et non une caricature de malveillance gratuite. Incisif et complexe dans le rôle de Crassus, Vladimir Mozgovoj fait le paon en public mais baisse la garde dans l’intimité. Il convient de souligner que ses enchaînements de doubles tours en tournant étaient absolument électrisants.
Tu veux la bagarre?
Spartacus (Sergei Bobrov). Photography courtesy of Varna International Ballet
Alors que dans la version de Grigorovitch, les mouvements d’ensemble mettaient en scène des soldats (ou des rebelles) évoluant côte à côte en formation, ici, les cohortes perdent leur aspect purement esthétique pour s’affronter dans ce qui s’apparente à un véritable combat. Malgré l’exiguïté de la scène en plein air de Varna, les entrées et les sorties sont orchestrées pour un effet maximal. Les danseurs surgissent et disparaissent de toutes parts, dans trois directions ou plus. Ici, soldats et gladiateurs se déchaînent véritablement.
Tout au long du ballet, on entend le fracas du métal contre le métal. L’angle dans lequel les épées sont plantées avec férocité « dans » l’adversaire, est si précisément calculé que l’action paraît étonnamment réelle. Les chutes des combattants abattus sont superbement dénuées d’artificialité; elles sont lourdes et vraies.
Bobrov parvient à donner du relief à cette abstraction qu’est « le peuple » en attribuant des pas spécifiques à un groupe ou à un personnage précis. Par exemple, nous savons que des bergers ont rejoint la révolte de Spartacus, mais Grigorovitch avait tendance à les fondre dans la masse anonyme de la foule. Ici, les pâtres brandissent leurs houlettes, les ancrent dans le sol avec rusticité lors de rondes folkloriques, exécutent des accroupissements maladroits et progressent même à reculons depuis les coulisses en une « chenille » incroyablement inventive — et hilarante — où ils avancent buste penché en avant ; une trouvaille que tout chorégraphe voyant ce spectacle sera assurément tenté de reprendre à son compte.
Les batailles sont non seulement pleines de surprises, mais elles se concluent toujours avec panache. Bobrov s’avère être un maître du tableau vivant, une approche payante tant sur le plan visuel que dramatique. Presque chaque scène s’achève sur une image saisissante (que je me garderai bien de dévoiler).
Les Faaaaaaames!
Spartacus (Sergei Bobrov). Photography courtesy of Varna International Ballet
Les femmes dans les anciennes productions ? Beaucoup de piétinés passifs et de retirés en parallèle pour les gentilles, comme moyen d’expression. Des bras frêles alternant avec des développés devant/sur le côté/derrière, et c’est à peu près tout. Les méchantes font le grand écart et ondulent des épaules en se penchant en arrière sur les genoux, dans une manière de danse gitane décadente. Évidemment.
Dans la chorégraphie de Bobrov, les esclaves domestiques sont espiègles et affirmées, à la manière du Chat Botté et la Chatte Blanche. Elles ont du swing. Mais surtout, Bobrov sort enfin au moins la moitié des femmes de la chambre à coucher en introduisant un rebondissement des plus rafraîchissants et bienvenu, ancré dans l’histoire. Saviez-vous que les Anciens mentionnent que la puissante et agile cohorte de gladiateurs comprenait des femmes réduites en esclavage ? Ainsi, Spartacus est ici uni à une égale, une combattante, plutôt qu’à un saule pleureur. Dans le rôle d’Achillea, la vaillante Natalia Bobrova passe de la force du roc à la souplesse d’une liane en un instant. Toujours prête à relever le prochain défi, elle semble même ne pas transpirer. J’ai dû même la soutenir plus que Spartacus quand, son épée à nouveau dégainée, elle affrontait Crassus en personne avant de mourir en homme.
Les nombreux pas de deux de Crassus et de sa concubine perse Roxane (interprétée avec majesté par Roberta Pereira, tour à tour coquette et féroce) contrastaient fortement avec ceux d’Achillea et de Spartacus, tant par leur intention que par leur émotion : plus incisifs, plus rapides, plus complexes. Roxane s’enroulait autour du général comme… un bretzel ?… un boa constrictor ? Leur vocabulaire spécifique incluait des grands écarts inversés qu’une gladiatrice courageuse et vertueuse comme l’Achillea de Bobrova aurait méprisés.
Toutes les femmes de cette production de Varna rayonnaient de confiance et de détermination. Lorsque Natalia Bobrova a exécuté des fouettés avec une conviction farouche, une épée dans chaque main, au cours de l’acte II, le public a acclamé cette nouvelle démonstration de virilité dansante. [Curieusement, le correcteur orthographique insiste pour que j’utilise la forme masculine de ce mot].
Spartacus (Sergei Bobrov). Photography courtesy of Varna International Ballet
Gaydar
Nous savons que les Romains étaient plutôt ouverts aux expérimentations sexuelles, surtout lorsqu’il s’agissait de découvrir de jeunes hommes séduisants. Qui plus est, les philosophes affirmaient souvent que le véritable amour, celui qui transforme l’être, ne pouvait naître qu’entre hommes, et non entre hommes et femmes.
Que ce soit dans un ballet, un film ou une bande dessinée, voir des hommes musclés, torse nu et en sueur, vêtus de cuir, devrait éveiller quelques soupçons, ne trouvez-vous pas ? Aucun chorégraphe ayant travaillé sur « Spartacus » auparavant n’avait osé aborder cette évidence. Il faut dire que la faute n’en incombait pas qu’aux puritains communistes : dans le blockbuster hollywoodien de 1960, la scène où Crassus faisait des avances lubriques à son esclave masculin — avec cette phrase d’accroche : « J’aime aussi bien les escargots que les huîtres » — a été rapidement coupée au montage.
Bobrov est le tout premier à prendre le taureau par les cornes, si l’on peut dire. Il a ajouté un cinquième rôle principal, et un personnage qui assume pleinement et fièrement sa nature. Loin d’être une simple distraction kitsch, Azar, l’esclave perse, apporte une dynamique très bienvenue à ce récit fait d’amour et de perte.
Ce rôle semble taillé sur mesure pour le talent unique de Vittorio Scole, artiste plein d’esprit et d’une souplesse incroyable. Ses grands écarts, ses déhanchements et ses extensions dépassant largement le 180°, sans oublier son impertinence malicieuse, seront difficiles à égaler. Son solo — « je vais utiliser ma propre barre pour m’amuser, merci » — a offert un moment de répit joyeux au milieu de tout ce drame ; un pur délice.
L’introduction d’une ambitieuse Queen, aux imperfections attachantes, au sein de la relation entre Crassus et Roxana — cette dominatrice manipulatrice — sert avant tout à humaniser davantage le général. Il est manifestement plus à l’aise avec cette « diva » qu’avec celle qui se prend pour Agrippine. La réaction viscérale de Crassus face à la mort violente d’Azar a renforcé le postulat du ballet : aucun homme n’est jamais totalement mauvais. La vie ne se résume pas au noir et au blanc ; elle regorge de zones grises et de rouges imprégnés de sang.
Spartacus (Sergei Bobrov). Photography courtesy of Varna International Ballet
Qu’elles défient le pouvoir ou qu’elles s’y soumettent, les œuvres d’art sont toujours ancrées dans une époque et un lieu donnés. Les scènes finales de toutes les adaptations théâtrales de « Spartacus » en témoignent. Le dénouement du film avec Kirk Douglas, par exemple, rendait un hommage on ne peut plus explicite à la solidarité de ceux qui avaient refusé de « dénoncer leurs semblables » durant la « Peur rouge » aux États-Unis.
Grigorovitch et Seregi (tout comme, j’imagine, Jacobson et Moïsseïev) savaient qu’il leur fallait offrir des finals exaltants. Le peuple a beau perdre la guerre, la supériorité morale, elle, perdure.
Qu’en est-il du final de Bobrov ? Personne ne sort vainqueur, loin de là. Ce tableau funèbre, abstrait et aux antipodes de l’héroïsme, s’inspire en réalité de la légende d’une fleur à laquelle nous prêtons rarement attention. Deux gladiateurs (dont probablement Spartacus lui-même) avaient refusé de s’entretuer. Ils avaient préféré planter leurs épées dans le sol, sachant qu’aucun des deux ne serait épargné. À cet endroit précis a jailli… un glaïeul. Saviez-vous que cette fleur symbolise la camaraderie, la solidarité et la non-violence ?
Des femmes sans hommes, drapées dans de longues tenues de mousseline noire [utilisée avec parcimonie dans cette production, Dieu merci], dansent pensivement — ou avec colère — en maniant des épées gainées de cette fleur. Lorsqu’ils se croisent dans les airs, ces instruments de mort dessinent même des formes de papillons, comme s’ils aspiraient à s’envoler. Mais soudain, elles sont braquées vers nous avant d’être violemment plantées dans le plancher de la scène. Au diable cette violence sans fin !
L’épopée de Bobrov, dont une tournée européenne est prévue pour la saison prochaine, s’avère plus que jamais d’actualité à une époque où les grandes puissances s’estiment encore et toujours en droit d’opprimer des populations entières qu’elles jugent inférieures. Il était donc tout à fait opportun de présenter ce ballet en avant-première sur la terre natale de Spartacus, au bord de la mer Noire — une région autrefois appelée Thrace et aujourd’hui connue sous le nom de Bulgarie. Le lendemain matin, alors que je me promenais sur la plage en repensant au spectacle, j’avais du mal à croire que je me trouvais à deux pas d’un autre carnage absurde perpétré par les homme
Spartacus (Sergei Bobrov). Photography courtesy of Varna International Ballet
Commentaires fermés sur Spartacus in Varna : There And Back Again
Why on earth did we get so many tickets to this thing? After being stuck in a room endlessly watching endless rehearsals for La Bayadère on the phone during Covid, what did we get when the theaters reopened? More Baya. And now it’s back to Baya. I arrived at my first performance in a state of advanced gloom.
But during the overture I perked up. To my delight, for once the musicians in the pit had decided to take “ballet music” seriously and behave. Without the usual cringe-inducing woops and boops and jam-ups, Minkus sounded like real music. Koen Kessels’s reactive conducting made it evident for once that if someone was off the beat you knew whom to blame. This series was going to be bearable after all.
********
************
June 17th: An Enchanted Flute
Léonore Baulac’s poignant Nikiya immediately enveloped herself in the music. Dare I call her a dancing flute? A tuning fork? Sound and emotion shiver through her body and find release through her arms. She is melancholy, wistful, bust carefully placed forward … Giselle in Act II. Viscerally disgusted and shaken by the Grand Brahmin’s overtures, with Solor her back suddenly opened up and her arms grew even longer. This Nikiya believes completely in her handsome savior. When her hero swears his faith upon the pyre, she is clearly convinced, like Giselle, that true love lasts forever.
Léonore Baulac is at that “sweet spot” in her career where physical ability and artistry coincide. This allows her to take her roles to another level. Baulac’s Nikiya reacts with seemingly unrehearsed spontaneity to every situation she encounters.
In the Confrontation Scene — as with her Judith in Pina Bausch’s Bluebeard — she became increasingly like a small defenseless animal in pain, biting back as best as she could with tiny sharp teeth. In Act II, as Baulac began her fraught lament, I had the weird impression that she had lost weight during intermission. Emotions flickered, flowed, and intensified in cadence to the music. In Act III, our heroine seemed completely weightless, a gentle breeze. The way she held back a microsecond then echoed and amplified Solor’s movements made it clear that she was a delicate figment of his opium-induced dreams.
The best actors don’t “act,” they listen. Alas, given the rest of this cast on the 17th, Baulac could only rely upon the orchestra for support and release. Let’s face it, the much-maligned Minkus knew how to cue emotional verismo. This Nikiya, as graceful and fragile as a glass figurine, was stuck a world of tin soldiers.
Paul Marque had first jetéd in with soft, even languorous, authority. He knows how to make his grand leaps hover up there. His pantomime discussion with Daniel Stokes’s twitchy Fakir was clear and slow. But this gravitas evaporated the moment he returned to dancing. A kind of gritty determination – especially in pirouettes – more suited to a competition, took over. This continued to be a problem. He acted out surprise and unease at his forced marriage but then seemed to forget all about it during the Grand Pas. He’s been dancing a lot. Exhaustion plus adrenalin? In Act III he continued to interpret rushing as a kind of default mode for expressing despair.
As Gamzatti, Bluenn Battistoni continues to rely upon her technical finesse but, as an Étoile, she really needs to start working on her projection. Maybe I shouldn’t say this, but I’ve seen her now how many times yet have trouble recalling her face, identifying a persona. Is it her coach? Does she need contacts? Is it stage-fright? But ever since her Beauty a year ago, she only seems to begin to start to glow during a third act. And then she’s just lovely. The problem is that Gamzatti doesn’t have a third act… Battistoni’s Wedding Pas had an uneven feel. During the adagio she seemed coolly triumphant in a Black Swanny way but then disappeared into a very careful, hemmed-in variation that didn’t take advantage of the massive space on stage. Everything got tighter from pirouettes to arabesques, nothing stretched nor reached. Her Italian into regular fouetté’s were strong and perfect in the wrong way: she cranked them out with a kind of scary force.
Paul Marque and Léonore Baulac (Solor and Nikiya)Bleuenn Battistoni (Gamzatti)Paul Marque et Léonore Baulac (Solor et Nikiya)
********
************
June 29th: The Violin’s Plaint
Dorothée Gilbert. The audience, of course, exploded when she made her entrance.
Her Nikiya reminded me more of an Odette than a Giselle, cooler and warier than Baulac. I really did wonder whether this Nikiya hadn’t once been a real princess who had gotten trapped in a temple dancer’s body due to some evil spell or reincarnation gone wrong. She was damsel in distress, certainly, but wise beyond her years and neither vulnerable nor naïve. Just one sharp suspicious glance – plus a regal “you high caste, me not” snippet of pantomime – made the Grand Brahmin (Yann Chailloux, very King and I) wither. Gilbert’s distinctive face has long reminded me of that of the young Joan Crawford in her early days on screen. Like the actress, Gilbert radiates an inner strength and calm assurance, but beneath that façade wounds can plunge in deep.
Gilbert’s Nikiya throbbed more to the sound of plucked strings than to the call of the flute. Her sense of gravity is more vertical than Baulac’s: hers is a spine that refuses to bend just because the winds say so.
Hugo Marchand’s Solor started out as a flirtatious and playful suitor, an Albrecht confident that everything always ends well.
Gilbert sang quiet duets with her partner of long standing. They’ve had a much commented-upon alchemy since the beginning of their pairing. He can literally tell where she is even with his back turned to her, which made Act III even more compelling. Fans of G/M don’t kill me, but I found one flaw in this performance: it’s very uncommon for Gilbert to search for her balances. She seemed to be unable to release some tension in her shoulders which, through osmosis, spread to her partner.
Roxane Stojanov’s Gamzatti – no Black Swan, but an entitled Bathilde who expects protocol be followed — put a full stop to this romance. An Albrecht instead of a warrior, Marchand was much more visibly discomfited by the princess than Paul Marque had been on June 17th. You really saw him try to rebel against the Rajah’s dictates as he lurked and peeped from behind corners while trying to figure out what to do. When Act II took off, Stojanov’s Gamzatti knew she’d won and led all the way through the pas de deux with sovereign ease, not force. Marchand reacted progressively to his beloved’s pain in a way the other Solor visibly hadn’t. At one point, “I want to sink into a hole in the ground” was quite readable.
Act III allowed us to bask in Gilbertmarchand’s aura. We had the same soloists for the variations both nights and my impressions were mixed. Hohuyn Kang is usually a dance-y dancer. Like so many who have been cast in the First variation for years now, Kang needs to be told this simple fact: you just don’t need to lift that side leg up so high in the sissonne/developé/assemblé. This displaces your center, disrupts the flow of the combination, makes the music sound clunky, and, frankly, ruins the overall line. Inès McIntosh’s second variation impressed the audience with her combination of technical maestra and naturally shaped lines. Everything was luminous, nothing was overdone. That’s just the way she always dances. As Number 3, the talented Bianca Scudamore gave a surprisingly unmusical, even heavy, interpretation that progressed nowhere. No build-up, no humorous response to the the oom-pah-pah heft of the score. Scudamore is scheduled to dance Gamzatti when I go on July 8th. Let’s see what happens.
Dorothée Gilbert and Hugo Marchand (Solor and Nikiya)
********
************
July 3rd: A Muted Harp
I was, alas, bewildered and disappointed by Heloïse Bourdon’s Nikiya on July 3rd. The elegant simplicity and easy control of her dance remains evident, but here somehow the character seemed to elude her. More the pity because Germain Louvet’s impeccable and feverishly eager Solor did bring something out of her in Act 1, a kind of complicit, gleeful, bodily confidence that then vanished again once she got back to work as a devadasi. I had the feeling she been coached to a such a deep point of interiority that her Nikiya became mainly inscrutable. I held out hope when the Kingdom of the Shades began: Bourdon seemed to remember being alive, she followed the sound of the harp, her calls to Louvet with her arms were so warm that his Solor could only follow. Then, boom, for the rest of the act, the gentle ghost vanished, replaced by some kind of zombie. Literally expressionless, yet dominant, as if trying to wipe out their story rather than preserve it.
Bourdon had been, however, toweringly ferocious when she refused to be pushed around by Gamzatti è tutti quanti. You could see emotional pain running down Bourdon’s spine as her body reached out to tell her story during Act II. “How can you forget us so fast, Solor?” Aha, I thought, so this is why Myrtha’s is still so pissed off after almost two centuries. Have you ever wondered about the Queen of the Wilis’s backstory? Well, here you have it.
And who wouldn’t be infuriated by Clara Mousseigne’s simpering Gamzatti? A princess? Nah. Louvet/Solor’s deftly acted slow burn of realization that this Bathilde 2.0 turns out to be just an empty shell in good clothes made you hope he’d go off script, grab that snake, and shove it down her bodice.
Mousseigne has always danced with efficiency but without a drop of that generosity, lift, or distilled feminine elegance is the very definition of a ballerina. Her extensions don’t extend beyond her toes. Her double attitude turns that finish in arabesque plié, for example, didn’t thrill precisely because she seemed to be saying “I control this and make the music – and everybody — wait for me.” She knows exactly how to fouetté for maximum applause. She can show off but clearly does not use her body to serve the persona that is embedded in the music. She flaps her hands instead.
My antipathy for this dancer would be reconfirmed by her variation as the First Shade on July 8. A mechanical doll with a tin ear? Worse, she was the only Shade who smiled all the way through Act III. Isn’t it great to be dead?
Clara Mousseigne (Gamzatti)Germain Louvet (Solor)Héloïse Bourdon (Nikiya) et Keita Belali (le Fakir)
********
************
La Bayadère. Corps de Ballet des ombres. Saluts
July 8th: Encore
Léonore Baulac again, but with a new lover and a new nemesis.
Guillaume Diop soars in, more connected to his feet than I’d seen lately. He demonstrates a new kind of maturity and adult manliness. Rubens Simon’s rabbity Fakir doesn’t overdo the “yes, massa” stuff and shows a bit of stage intelligence: just why were all the other Fakirs clapping so hard when the whole point is not to wake up the Grand Brahmin?
Baulac and Diop fit well together. Their lines and rhythms, their sense of call and response, match. Indeed, both unfurl their arms with the same soft inflections. Their arms together reminded me of tendrils or the lianas in the set design. This gave their partnering a delicious Art Nouveau look. This pliant couple is not in the throes of passion but in the giddy bliss of innocent love.
As an actress, Bianca Scudamore was most believable as Gamzatti. When this sheltered princess realizes that there is something called “a rival,” her astonishment feels real, intense, and not overcooked. Indeed, these three made you feel that they were all equally naïve.
The way Scudamore crafted her character’s emotional arc from perplexed surprise into viperine fury was positively operatic. She offered Baulac, the most reactive of acting dancers, a real sparring partner. You could almost hear high notes. If someone ever concocts “Aida: The Ballet,” Scudamore would be my first choice for Amneris.
In the Grand Pas, Scudamore put on a cat that swallowed the canary face and led the dance. I chuckled when she gripped Diop’s hands and sharply pulled him closer, already a wife who insists upon proprieties in public. Her dance was strong and precise, if sometimes a bit earthbound. She smoothed over a few moments of not really being in tune with the music and roused the audience with plenty of double fouettés.
Of all the Gamzatti’s, Scudamore’s stayed the most reactive while seated to the side during Nikiya’s big moment, growing increasingly wistful as Diop’s Solor kept avoiding her gaze. In the original Giselle, Bathilde shows up in the forest to take a devastated Albrecht back home to the castle. I could see this Gamzatti doing just that.
Meanwhile, I haven’t mentioned the Golden Idols. Antoine Kirscher’s on June 17th and July 3 were, how to most kindly to describe it, lopsided and clenched. Thomas Doquir’s tight arabesque and heavy reliance on the beat limited his more solid, but overly careful, version on the 29th. But on this night, Andrea Sarri – alternately sharp and smooth, hieratic and almost human – reminded us that he is supposed to be a metal statuette brought to life by music.
On the 3rd and 8th of July, Act III also provided other casts for the variations. In the first, Camille Bon on the 3rd did find the right balance and avoided the trap of that raised leg. Her developés unfolded as, and into, part of a larger sense of movement. Saki Kuwabara’s second variation on the 3rd, brisk and fluid, holds up when compared to Marine Ganio’s on the 8th. I don’t know how many times I’ve seen Ganio in this variation, but you can never tire of her creamy precision. Her dance is like a string of pearls. I was immensely lucky to see Nine Seropian twice as the Third Shade. A dancer with fine musical and theatrical intelligence, she clearly understood that this is a waltz, and that a waltz is not “one-two-three-wait” but “one-two-three-aaand.” Let me put it this way: I’ve had more than enough of La Bayadère for now, but the day either Seropian or Ganio gets cast as one of the leads, I’ll be ready for more..
Léonore Baulac and Guillaume Diop (Solor and Nikiya).
Roméo et Juliette, Paris Opera Ballet, Opera Bastille, April 7, 8, and 17, 2026. Choreography by Rudolf Nureyev, Music by Sergei Prokofiev, Sets and Costumes [sort of] by Ezio Frigerio
Not one of the three evenings I attended was “bad.” But not one couple pierced me to the core, either. I realize I made a weird note during one performance: “Why is this ballet just not happening?”
Perhaps I could not concentrate because another tragedy was playing out on stage at the same time. What has the Paris Opera management done to Ezio Frigerio’s claustrophobically textured and vivid scenic environment? I thought I was hallucinating. No fountain? All the rich backcloths and detailed carvings replaced by what were basically sky templates enlarged off the internet? A cheap showroom bed plonked in the middle of an empty warehouse is now the crypt? Speaking of cheap, the regilt mobile flies were way too flashy.
The lighting design remains unchanged, yet the sets that the lighting refracted off have now mostly disappeared, along with about half the extras. The downstage “alea jacta est” dice players were rendered invisible both at curtain up and curtain down. The Duke of Verona, who appears upstage to force the warring clans to put down their swords was literally invisible all three nights. On the other hand, the guests entering the Capulet doors, who once had become shadows behind a scrim, are painfully visible as they head for the wings obscured by…nothing. Can it get worse? Yes. During the balcony scene, a spot hits the couple. Without the fountain, it lofts the shadow of their heads onto the bland backdrop that now only consisted of an out-of-focus polaroid moon. The result look exactly like an upside down “wow” emoticon. Do better next time, guys.
*
* *
April 7th
Paul Marque and Sae Eun Park Performance on April 7th.
I have come to like Sae Eun Park, the performer. I have come to like Paul Marque in the same vein. I continue to dislike seeing them dance together. When Park/Marque is cast they continue to radiate the calm of their clearly pleasant rehearsal room relationship. When they are alone or with others they can glow, they react. Germain Louvet catalyzed a striking vulnerability in Park’s Giselle. In Sylvia, you just yearned for the wildly ardent Marque to end up happily ever after with Bluenn Battistoni…
They are very much “in like,” but their chemistry lacks radiance, abandon. There is no electric “spark” between them, only a comfort zone. Yet they continue to be scheduled as dramatic leads together …
Maybe something was off from the start because the first real potential girlfriend you had already seen — Sylvia Saint-Martin’s icy, dry, and monotone Rosalind — made you already wonder what was wrong with this Romeo. Why would any young man in his right mind waste time trying to flirt with a humorless poppet? Overheard during intermission: “there was no Rosalind tonight, just a bunch of identical girls.” Ouch.
Sae Eun Park’s Juliet was light and quick and warm, but soon you could see how she was always being carefully managed by Tybalt and Romeo – and even her father — when it came to sliding her down or manipulating her in any way whatsoever. The fact that she offered up the same gracious smile to each and every person quickly started to bore me. There was no sense of shock in her first encounter with Romeo in the Ball Scene, which came off as more of a hello. Park does lean into Marque with soft grace, but even when his mask falls off Park’s Juliet remains the same well-bred girl. His first kiss doesn’t light her up with more than a “that was nice.” Nor did the second.
In the balcony scene Marque’s Romeo was full out at first, open-bodied and visibly inspired to impress Juliet (that recklessly precise manège of double tours)… and then he reversed gears and became the “I won’t break this glass unicorn” careful partner. Why? Honestly, Park looks as if she is in perfectly fine shape and uninjured. Despite the restraint, a certain soft charm did manage to evolve. Was I moved? No. Act Three just seemed endless until Marque’s Romeo, alone, began to storm his way unto his death. Park’s death scene was moving in equal measure. How odd, isn’t it, that both their most passionate moments occurred while the other was inert?
All the more pity as so many on stage April 7th had energy and wit to spare:
Jack Gasztowtt, aware and alert, fully present on stage as Benvolio.
What’s not to like about Francesco Mura’s bouncy and sly Mercutio, except for a terrible hairdo?
Jérémy Loup-Quer’s observant and actually likeable Tybalt definitely knows how to swish and slash his sword with relaxed authority. He was very much amused and reactive in the early scenes. Never a villain in the making. And that proved interesting: his courtly restraint as bad guy made Mercutio’s (and his own) fate all the more surprising.
Andrea Sarri’s Paris quickly evolved from fatuous plot device into husband material early on. He gave this dead-end role heft and elegance.
Sara Kora Dayanova’s Lady Capulet was a vortex of emotions, born out of the wisdom distilled by her years of on-stage experience. Most haughtily Shakespearian whilst she handed out swords during the ball scene, Dayanova’s later howl of desperation, not anger, stilled the house. Splendid and deeply alive on stage even when just walking – Dayanova doesn’t get a picture or a bio in the illustrated program. As if she were an extra? That’s just wrong. I heartily wish the Paris Opera Ballet would show more respect for those soloists who have given their lives to this company as they age gracefully and evolve more fully into character roles.
A young friend, who saw exactly the same cast a week later, hesitated when I interrogated him. “Oh it was excellent, so well-performed, the couple was really nice and then…At the end when he threw her body around, it was very aesthetic.” Alas he used code words for: your brain is on, not your heart. You are observing the process. He spoke too much about how he loved the costumes, bad sign. He was more captivated by the chemistry between Gastowtt’s Benvolio, Mura’s Mercutio, and Quer’s Tybalt. Now there he saw sparks flying, now there bloomed a galvanizing subtext he couldn’t shake out of his head.
*
* *
April 8th
Bleuenn Battistoni and Thomas Docquir. Performance on April 8th
The next night, after another impeccably danced performance, again I left the theater hungry for more. Unlike American critics, I have not so far felt I’d experienced what they sneeringly call the “too perfect” performances of the Paris Opera Ballet. But on the second night I started – for the first time ever – to muse that the principals just might have been over-rehearsed. Is that possible?
Even before Juliet’s entrance, I’d been tempted by what Hohyun Kang’s fluffy and flirty Rosalind had to offer. Kang is one of those soloists who keeps catching the light. Pablo Legassa’s limber and graphic Tybalt could have been naughtier (on the 17th, Nicola di Vico will carve out a splashily dashing silent movie villain who really has the ear of Katherine Higgins’s chillingly ambitious Lady Capulet). Andrea Sarri’s Mercutio had joyous energy to spare. Keita Bellali used the role of Paris to display his silky control and gorgeous lines as a peacock would. Bellali even managed to indicate that he might have some secret passions simmering just below the surface, too.
Everything Bluenn Battistoni’s Juliet does flows so naturally that you take her unforced – but powerfully developed — technique for granted. Her Juliet on April 8th accelerated, decelerated, nuanced little flicks of leg or hand, slowly loosened up. Her dance is beautifully silky…but it wasn’t until the third act that she took over the narrative and made it impossible not to watch her.
Her Romeo was Thomas Docquir. His trajectory in this company has been awkward. Every time I’ve seen him over the years he’s clearly been concentrating on extending his lines and technique, especially in the service of the tricky syncopations and changes of direction in Nureyev’s ballets. But something never quite happened. Endlessly cast as a perfectly acceptable Rothbart “de service” one season, then miscast as a mild Frollo, with a Prince Desiré in between (where he seemed petrified by imposter syndrome). And here? …here he was deeply sweet and finally relieved from whatever it was that had been holding him back. So I was rooting for him.
Docquir’s Romeo is very much in the vein of Tony in West Side Story, a passionate pacifist. He really draws in the audience when he pleads “I don’t, I won’t, I can’t” when prodded by his friends or by Tybalt. But with his Juliet, alas, once again, sparks just didn’t happen until the last act. Thomas Docquir – like Paul Marque the night before – kept disappearing into partner mode.
*
* *
April 17th
Romeo & Juliet. Performance on April 17th.
And then, unexpectedly, Thomas Docquir was thrust into a new partnership with Valentine Colasante on April 17th due to Guillaume Diop cancelling due to injury. And maybe this wasn’t such a bad idea.
While this couple also didn’t make me cry, the fact that they had been working in different directions with equal intensity in rehearsals gave their interactions a spontaneity that had been lacking in the other pairings.
Colasante’s playful “don’t worry, I won’t break” Juliet just wants to dance with her besties and no one, not even this rather cute Paris (Bellali again) was going to make her simply smile at everyone and obey. I sighed along with her easy loping pensive walk out onto the terrace and into the Balcony Scene. Docquir’s “Maybe Tonight” attitude made her visibly brighten. The duet on the 17th had an amplitude that was lacking on the 7th or 8th, perhaps due to the fact that when a new partner comes at you with a different center of gravity, then you are forced to concentrate on getting through the moment, rather than perfecting the look. So what if a few landings are hard, some lifts a bit short, and maybe timing is sometimes half a beat away from in-sync? In a dramatic ballet is partnering supposed to be predictably pretty? Imperfection creates a sense of spontaneity. When Docquir’s Romeo struggled both intentionally and unintentionally with Colasante’s drugged body near the end, it felt raw. This drama was happening here and now on stage, not copy-pasted from a rehearsal studio.
Empty backdrops and over-guilded decor for this revival…
George Balanchine’s Theme and Variations, Mthuthuzeli November’s Rhapsodies, Christopher Wheeldon’s Corybantic Games.
October 17th and 18th, 2025, at the Opéra Bastille in Paris.
This new season the triple bills are advertised under teaser catch-all titles that make no sense whatsoever. The one I’ve seen twice in a row is entitled “Racines” [aka “Roots”]. Now, as far as the Paris Opera Ballet goes, what do Balanchine, November (a newcomer), and Wheeldon have to do with our “roots?” Tchaikovsky, Gershwin, Bernstein? Well, if you are an American, the latter two just might work as far as your roots go.
I walked in — and alas left — the Opera Bastille both evenings still unable to find the answer. Came home rooted around the refrigerator, in search of comfort and inspiration. I know this sounds like what am I about to write will be pretty gnarly, but please bear with me.
Once I’m done, I’m going to finally look at the essays in the program book and see if that adds some enlightenment.
*
* *
Theme & Variations.
Zucchini Blossoms/ George Balanchine’s Theme and Variations (1947)
Have you ever planted zucchini in your garden? It just never stops sneakily extending its roots in all directions. By the end of the season you just cannot even look at even one more piece of your neighbor’s redundant zucchini bread. That’s Sleeping Beauty, tasty, but two long runs of it last season turned out to be more than filling.
Zucchini blossoms offer a delicate synecdoche for all that raw bounty. They are, in a sense, all the flavor concentrated into one juicy fried mouthful. Maybe this is one way to define how Theme and Variations distills Sleeping Beauty: the essence is there, minus the endless fairies.
Unfortunately, there are as many opinions out there about THE “authentic” way to dance Balanchine technique as there are recipes that do, or do not, include nutmeg. Ben Huys of THE Trusts (both Balanchine and Robbins!) was the invited coach. This ballet, despite its surprising construction – the ballerina barely gets to breathe during the first half and then mostly polonaises around for the rest – always turns out to be very tasty.
So let’s just enjoy the show and take a look at the dancers.
On October 17th, from the initial danced statement of the theme up to their deeply elegant réverances, both Bleuenn Battistoni and Thomas Docquir were still clearly inside their heads as Aurora and Désiré from last spring. And they continued to be that way, all the way through. But, as the last time, there was just 1% missing. A dash of pepper. Battistoni reiterated the unemphatic grace of her first act Aurora: all about just the right uplift and épaulements and un-showy but oh-so centered rock-solid balances. But this performance could also use just one more pinch of spice. Docquir, as he did last spring, concentrated on making his steps and jumps and batterie as scholastically perfect as possible. His performance wasn’t radiant. In princely roles, he seems to be fighting imposter syndrome. He rushed the music in partnering at times.
Honestly, this Theme was lovely, courtly, polished. The soft and precise landings into every pose at the end of a sequence literally pulled the audience in. I noticed that my neighbor kept leaning forward towards the stage each time, as if she had been swept up into 18th century courtesies, impelled to bow in return.
October 17th 2025. Bleuenn Battistoni & Thomas Docquir. Theme & Variations.
With Valentine Colasante and Paul Marque on October 18th, Theme felt looser and more fun. It was Beauty, but Act 3. Colasante luxuriated into the movements and teeny-weeny stretch-the-movement-out just enough beyond the axis to make a swish-swish seem new. She danced big, fearlessly, and playfully dared to hover a microsecond too long. Both dancers caressed the air and the floor. And there was something intriguing about the way Marque partnered: he seemed to catch her before the lifts, rather than on the way down, if that makes sense.
After the ballet, I thought about this very French concept of “la belle presentation.” Have you ever looked into a shop window in Paris where all the foodstuffs – from succulent to basic — are beautifully organized? Even bouquets of radishes are carefully placed in delicate patterns. Theme and Variations definitely suits our sense of l’art de vivre.
Valentine Colasante & Paul Marque.
Paul Marque. Theme & Variations.
On both nights, I overheard complaints about the tiny corps on occasion not getting to their places and not lining up properly. Yes, yes, I did see it: one of the four girl soloists, and then especially when the male corps showed up. It’s not worth it to name names, as we have Giselle and a tour going on and are spread thin. Quite a few in the tutus and tights were newish to the stage. I find this critique particularly funny as Paris Opera Ballet is often accused of being too perfect from top to bottom.
As Balanchine would say, “who cares?”
*
* *
Rhapsodies. Magda Willi for Mthuthuzell November’s Rhapsodies.
Fennel and Endive /Mthuthuzeli November’s Rhapsodies (2024)
Who knows what to do with fennel or endives? Braise? Slice down in some direction and drench in lemon? No matter what, you have no answers. Maybe they just aren’t meant to be cooked.
Maybe Gershwin’s Rhapsody in Blue – by a composer who wrote pop music but wanted to be taken seriously – just isn’t meant to be used for a ballet?
Other choreographers have taken it on. In Paris, Odile Duboc did in 1999. It was insipid and has long gone into the dustbin.
Mthuthuzeli November’s take on the music has a lot more going for it. Or does it?
A clever set that leaves you puzzled, to start with. The outlines of wooden door frames are highlighted by led lights. The frames are attached to each other and can be pulled out like accordions and wheeled around or reshaped into one square outline as clouds of dried ice float by. I thought of Olafur Eliasson’s “Inside the Horizon,” that unfolding series of slivered reflections at the Louis Vuitton Foundation. I began to recall the many times Jean Cocteau made characters walk through mirrors in his films. My seatmate – after we made a pact that we would both not put our noses into the program beforehand – concentrated hard and said she saw people trying to step away from their cellphones. A French friend had seen French windows.
So the set gets you from the get-go, even if your mind drifts back to how many choreographers have used moving sets to incite and inspire movement since the beginning of time…
And does the dance get your attention? It’s perfectly watchable, nicely thought out.
On the 17th in the lead couple Celia Drouy, sensual and rounded, was the charming girl next door. I’d love to see her in Dances at a Gathering. It was odd then, late in the piece, when she shoved away her partner, the cooly intense Axel Ibot. It seemed to come out of nowhere.
October 17th 2025. Rhapsodies.
The dance? Watchable and performed with energetic commitment by all. The cast was filled with skilled soloists who are only occasionally ever cast in big roles, such as Ibot (eye-catching here and equally focused the next night when he rejoined the corps) or Fabien Révillion (a delightful Colas long ago and a wrenching Lensky recently). I often watch for Isaac Lopes Gomes, cleanly and powerfully performing no matter what line he’s stuck in. Daniel Stokes. Juliette Hilaire. Charlotte Ranson…
Ah yes the dance. Forgot that one. Weight down but pulled up. A repeated group movement of squats in second thump forward while swaying side to side à la les drinking buddies in Prodigal Son. Open your arms to the sun and close them at varied speeds. Embracing the sky is common to almost all local world dances as well as yoga. Push and pull. As a young woman once said to me after she tried a baguette for the first time and did not want to seem ignorant: “I wasn’t amazed, but it was soft, it was crunchy, it was warm! It was soft and crunchy! Wasn’t it supposed to be soft and crunchy?”
On the 18th I think another layer got added to Rhapsodies. Letizia Galloni was laid back/avid, out-of-here/imperious, chiseled/pliant. She projected a mysterious anguish and tension which made you notice from the start that she was indeed pushing back at her partner, Yvon Demol. Even when Galloni yields, she holds something back.
Letizia Galloni is another one of those soloists whose career has switched on and off and on. Talented and eye-catching from the time she graduated the POB school, she scored La Fille Mal Gardée during the Millepied era about ten years ago. Then she faded into herself. Then disappeared. (At least here in a national company, you can go into hibernation without being fired). But she popped up again last spring in Sleeping Beauty and offered the audience one of the loveliest Gold and Silvers I’ve seen in many a year: relaxed, imperious, generous, impeccable technically, with a sense of bounce and sweep that made us in the audience glad for her.
Axel Ibot (soloist on the 17 th). Yvon Demol and Letizia Galloni (soloists on the 18th).
Celia Drouy (Soloist on the 17th) and Fabien Revillion
*
* *
October 17th 2025. Corybantic Games.
Turnips/ Christopher Wheeldon’s Corybantic Games (2018)
Un “navet” aka turnip is the French way to say “that was a real dud.” I could have called this ballet a turkey, but we being very svelte and are only going to eat veggies today.
This thing, created for The Royal Ballet in 2018, has no structure (dramatic or balletic), no core, and dithers endlessly along. My seatmate on the 17th called it “soporific.” I thought of nastier words but simply nodded. I seriously considered skipping it on the 18th. Once was more than enough.
The pretty costumes are white with black ribbons crisscrossed across the torso that then dangle down from the shoulders. During the second night’s curtain calls, I tried to see if there was some sense to the danglers. Seems like the more of a soloist you are, the more ribbons.
The pretentious music is by Leonard Bernstein whenever he windily demands to be taken seriously. I’d call it Bride of Agon. The choreography, equally self-infatuated, proffers up innumerable quotes from just about every ballet that had an Antique World-y theme to the point that you could use it as a quiz: Note down the minute and the second where this choreographer directly cites Nijinsky, Nijinska, Robbins, Balanchine, Taylor. From Faun(s) to Apollo to Antique Elegies, this whole ballet felt like some snarky schoolboy’s inside joke. Flexed heels and upside-downsies and, as my seatmate noted, a lot of great final poses that turn out to be just a hook for more of the same. The Third Movement pas de deux ends with the guy hurling the girl up and into the wings (to be caught). Just where have I seen that one before?
It just goes on and on. I am too tired to describe it. Only a few days later I stare at my scribbled notes and all images of actual movement have faded. The steps from scene to scene – indeed within one — never get individuated. I’m looking at the cast list, filled with up-and-coming and cherished dancers and it’s painful. People tried to shine, gave it their all, but.
In the last scene, a soloist turns up (Valentina Colasante on the 17th and Roxane Stojanov on the 18th). Clearly, she is supposed to mean something, but what? Yes, I did know who the Corybantes were and that their earth mother is the fertility goddess Cybele (pretentious me) but what I didn’t see was one drop of wild ecstatic energy — not even once! — during these long minutes (37 minutes says the program, felt at least twenty minutes longer).
So now I’m looking at the program notes. Oh! Games is about Plato’s Symposium and polyamory! A less sexy or sensual ballet you will never find. No one connects. Ever. It turns out that in the fourth movement, if you look closely, the three couples are a straight, a male, and a lesbian one. Ooh! Did I look for boobies at all while three pairs of soloists in low light diddled around before settling into lovely enlaced poses on the downstage lip like teddy bears going to beddy? Seriously? As a female, I should note that women of any kind had no legal status or interest at all to Ancient Greek life or thought. Plato didn’t give a flying…hoot… about women, gay or straight. Why didn’t Wheeldon just make a dance about men being men who then tolerate a female diva who shows up for the grand finale? A fun fact is that Cybele’s male followers often castrated themselves at the apex of their delirium. Come to think about it, I don’t think that would make for a great ballet either.
As far as the title “Roots” goes, the program book insists that Wheeldon’s roots are in Greece. Seriously? He’s about as English as they come. As for Mthuthuzeli November, the program talks less about his native origins and much more about his discovery of ballet. This program should have been entitled « Apples and Oranges with a Dried-Out Raisin on The Side. »
Could someone please pass the salt?
Commentaires fermés sur « Racines » at the Paris Opera : How to Cook Roots
Manuel Legris’s Sylvia, Palais Garnier, May 8th & 9th
Sandwiched in there, between Belles, we were treated to a short run of a revival/re-do of the ballet Sylvia, which had disappeared from the Paris repertoire.
I had never seen Darsonval’s 1979 version, alas. I will always regret how the Paris Opera then also deprogrammed the one I knew: John Neumeier’s late 1990’s visually stunning version but esoteric re-interpretation of the story. It did take a while to figure out that Eros and Orion had been conflated into the same dancer by Neumeier, yet the choreographer’s vivid sense stagecraft worked for me emotionally. All the better that Neumeier’s original naïve shepherd, Aminta/Manuel Legris himself, decided to try to piece together a new version that reached back to the ballet’s classic roots.
It was particularly odd to see most of the Sleeping Beauty casts now let loose/working overtime on this new production. While the dancers gave it their all, quite a few of the mythical beings were sabotaged by a production that included some very distracting costumes and wigs.
The Goddess Diana sports a basketweave ‘80’s Sheila Easton mohawk that would make any dancer look camp. In the role, a rather ferocious Roxane Stojanov held her head up high and ignored it, while the next evening a tepid Silvia Saint-Martin disappeared underneath the headgear to the point I had forgotten about her by the time she reappeared on stage near the conclusion. The interactions between Diana and Endymion make no sense whatsoever, particularly when you are at the top of the house and cannot see what is happening on the little raised platform at the back of the stage. Imagine trying to follow the plot when you can only see a bit of someone’s body wiggling, but without a head. Note to designers: go sit up at the top of the house and do some simple geometric calculations of vectors, please.
To add to audience discomfort (hilarity?) with the staging at some point Eros, the God of Love, will abruptly rip open the raggedy cloak he’d been disguised in (don’t ask) in order to flash his now simply gold-lamé-jockstrap-clad physique. On the 9th, Jack Gasztowtt managed to negotiate this awkward situation with dignity. On the 8th, having already gotten mega-entangled in his outerwear just prior to the reveal, Guillaume Diop didn’t. Seriously cringey.
There are many more confusing elements to this version, including the strong presence of characters simply identified as “A Faun” (Francesco Mura both nights) and “A Nymph” (a very liquid Inès MacIntosh on the 8thand a floaty Marine Ganio on the 9th). But what’s with the Phrygian bonnets paired with Austrian dirndls? The Flames of Paris meet the Sound of Music on an Aegean cruise?
In Act 3, some characters seem to wear Covid masks. So please keep the choreography, but definitely junk these costumes!
Despite these oddities, dancers were having serious fun with it, as if they had been released from their solemn vow to Petipa while serving Beauty.
On the 8th of May, Germain Louvet’s fleet of foot and faithful shepherd Aminta charmed us. His solo directed towards Diana’s shrine touched in how grounded and focused it was. His Sylvia, Amandine Albisson, back after a long break, seemed more earthbound and more statuesque than I’d ever seen her, only really finding release from gravity when she had to throw herself into and out from a man’s arms. But when Albisson does, gravity has no rules. Usually you use the term “partnering” to refer to the man, but I always have the feeling that she is more than their match. When I watch Albisson abandon all fear I often think back to Martha Swope’s famous photograph of Balanchine’s utterly confident cat Mourka as she flies in the air. When it’s Albisson, everything gravity-defying, up to and including a torch lift, feels liberatingly feline rather than showy or scary.
Here the hunter Orion is less from Ovid and more of a debauched pirate straight out of Le Corsaire. On the 8th, Marc Moreau at first moved with soft intention, clearly more of a suitor than a rapist where Sylvia was concerned. You felt kind of sorry for him. His switch to brutality made sense: being unloved is bad enough for a guy, being humiliated by a girl in front of his minions would make any gang leader lash out.
Marc Moreau (Orion), Amandine Albisson (Sylvia) and Germain Louvet (Aminta)
On the 9th, I had to rub my eyes. Bleuenn Battistoni – that too demure Beauty – provided the relaxed and flowing and poignant princess I had hoped to see way back in March. Nothing dutiful here. Already in the first tableau, without doing anything obviously catchy, her serene and more assertive feminine authority insured that the audience could immediately tell she was the real heroine – an eye-catching gazelle. Maybe Beauty is just too much of a monument for a young dancer? Inhibiting? Ironically, at the end of the season, I would see Albisson let loose as Beauty. The tables will have turned.
I was drawn to Paul Marque’s melancholy and yearning shepherd Aminta. At a certain point, Sylvia will be prodded by Diana to shoot her suitor. Albisson did. Here Battistoni (and who in any case would obey Saint-Martin’s dry Diana?) clearly does by accident, which made the story juicier. Battistoni’s persona was vulnerable, you stopped looking at the “steps” even during the later Pizzicati solo, which she tossed off with teasing and pearly lightness. Everything I had hoped for in Battistoni’s Beauty showed up here.
Sylvia : Paul Marque et Bleuenn Battistoni
*
* *
The Belles Are Ringing
La Belle au Bois Dormant’s second series. Opera Bastille, June 27th,July 6th and 7th.
Guillaume Diop et Amandine Albisson (Désiré et Aurore le 7 juillet).
And then, boom, Albisson full out in Sleeping Beauty on July 7th. As fleet of foot as I knew her to be, neither allegory nor myth but a real and embodied character. Whereas she had seemed a bit too regal as Sylvia, here came the nymph. Delicate and gracious in the way she accepted the compliments of all of her suitors, Albisson created a still space around her whence she then began to enchant her princes. She looked soundless.
Guillaume Diop, who had proven a bit green and unsettled earlier this series, woke up his feet, leaned into his Second Act solo as he hadn’t before – a thinking presence, as someone remarked to me – and then went on to be galvanized by his partner and freed by the music.
Perhaps Diop, like everyone else on the stage, was breathing a sigh of relief. For this second series of Beauties in June/July, the brilliant and reactive conductor Sora Elisabeth Lee replaced the insufferable Vello Pähn. During the entire first series in March and April, this Pähn conducted as slowly and gummily if he were asleep, or hated ballet, or just wanted to drag it out so the stagehands got overtime. With Sora Elisabeth Lee, here the music danced with the dancers and elated all of us. During the entire second series, Bluebirds were loftier, dryads were more fleet-footed. Puss and Boots had more punch and musical humor. Sora Elisabeth Lee gave the dancers what they needed: energy, punchlines, real rhythm. This was Tchaikovsky.
So this second series was a dream.
On July 6th, Germain Louvet proved that he has grown into believing he can see himself as a prince. I say this because I was long perturbed by what he said as a young man in his autobiography (written before you should really be writing an autobiography). An assertive prince, a bit tough and perfectly cool with his status as Act Two starts. And then he began unfurling his solo, telling his story to the heavens. His arms had purpose, his hands yearned. And when he saw his Beauty, Hannah O’Neill, it was an OMG moment.
As it had been destined to be. O’Neill’s coltish and gracious and sleek, sweetly composed and well-mannered maiden from Act One was now definitely a damsel in need of a knight in shining armor. She was his dream, no question. She began her Second Act solo as if she were literally pushing clinging ivy aside, her arms moving slowly and filling into spaces at the end of each phrase. No wonder that Louvet’s prince became increasingly nervous seconds later while trying to find his girl in among the sleepers. You could feel his tension. “Are they all dead? Was the Lilac fairy just fooling with me?” And, oh, Act Three. The way he presented his belle, the way they danced for each other.
Hannah O’Neill (Aurore) et Germain Louvet (Désiré)
But of all the Beauties, I will never forget Leonore Baulac’s carefree and technically spot-on interpretation, maybe because I just can’t find a way to describe this June 27th performance in words. Fabulous gargouillades? The way she made micro-second connections with all four of her suitors (and seemed to prefer the one in red)? The way everything was there but nothing was forced? The endless craft you need to create the illusion of non-stop spontaneity? The way Marc Moreau just suited her? Those supported penchées and lean backs in the Dream Scene as one of the most perfect distillations of call and response I have ever seen?
Both Baulac and Moreau sharply etched their movements but always made them light and rounded and gracious. Phrases were extended into the music and you could almost hear whispered words as they floated in the air. They parallelled each other in complicity and attack to the point that the first part of the final pas de deux already felt as invigorating as a coda.
Léonore Baulac et Marc Moreau (Aurore et Désiré).
You can never get enough of real beauty. Let’s hope 2025’s Paris fall season will be as rich in delight.
Commentaires fermés sur My Spring Season 2025 in Paris 2/2 : A Beauty Binge with Nymphs on the side.
Sleeping Beauty/La Belle au Bois Dormant. Paris, Opera Bastille.
March 11, 13, 22 and April 3rd, 2025.
Stagecraft
Sleeping Beauty made me fall in love with ballet but at the same time, each time I see it, I begin wonder just why at some point (I still cannot pinpoint when), this ballet starts taking too long. Something could be cut. But what, where, when? And why?
I’m still stuck pondering this question decades later, even as this ballet makes me feel like a bee just gob-smacked by all the pollen out there on stage, bemusedly happy to just sit and watch a swarm of dancers bumble around in all the colors of its endlessness.
March 13th and April 3rd. During first intermission, I met up with some young American dancers. To my dismay, they assumed that Bluenn Battistoni had just graduated from the Paris Opera Ballet school and was being given her first big chance. I tried to argue that the French style, like the French people, is modest and reserved, more about perfection rather than chutzpah. (The company has been eternally misunderstood by those many American critics who value flash). But I didn’t even manage to convince myself. Battistoni’s dancing is absolutely stunning and technically polished, but her stage presence was way too reserved – over-calm — this performance. I’m not saying she needs to sell out, just learn to catch the limelight a little more. She’s completely assured but not assertive enough. With the right coach I am sure Battistoni will move from inward-looking glow into eye-catchingly demure radiance.
Battistoni, on the second night, channeled a newly skippy feel to her hops and gargouillades. She was asserting herself more, aha, but remained soft-spoken.
Bleuenn Batistoni (Aurore) et Guillaume Diop (Désiré)
Inès McIntosh on March 11th was more extraverted but she, like Battistoni, would probably be better served right now by Balanchine’s clever abstraction of Sleeping Beauty’s formal magic: Theme and Variations. That is not to say that McIntosh didn’t offer a powerful mini-mad scene after her finger was pricked. McIntosh has undeniable presence, but she hasn’t yet grown into projecting that kind of distillation of womanliness offered by so many of the Auroras I’ve seen from Fonteyn on down. In the Vision Scene, she just didn’t know how to project vulnerability and yearning. At the end of the evening I left the theatre humming Don Q instead of SB.
Ines McIntosh. Aurore
March 22nd. Powerful yet demure radiance is exactly what Héloïse Bourdon embodies these days. She just glows. In her one shot this season as Princess Aurora, I was delighted by how she reminded me in her solos of where the choreography and music echo bits and pieces of her Fairy godmothers’ variations. The Prologue had come together to shape the personality of this princess. Bourdon’s hard-earned stagecraft (don’t get me started again on all the reasons she should have promoted ages ago) offers a gift to the audience. You don’t have to be a balletomane to feel that something big is happening, but if you are a balletomane you relish her mastery of both steps and nuance all the more. I was bewitched.
Bourdon Docquir March 22
On other nights I was reduced to sitting back and basking in the authority and easy confidence of the same Bourdon’s repeated brief stints as Sixth Fairy during the Prologue. This variation is normally given to THE Lilac Fairy, but alas Nureyev morphed Lilac into a separate and, when not mimed with authority, utterly insipid panto role. Why turn the juiciest solo into a random outing with no follow-through? Instead of a powerful ballerina/catalyst, THE fairy turns out to be a random junior dancer in a cut-out costume dominated by a big wig à la Lina Lamont from Singing in the Rain insipidly miming – with one cast exeption – “Oh Carabosse, you shouldn’t have come. No, no, no.”
Bourdon’s suitors in Act One clearly appreciated this well-bred Aurora in bloom. “A rose? How kind of you.” She wasn’t “selling it” in a flashy way, nevertheless the people sitting near me literally screamed at the end of the adagio and a young man right behind me gasped in shock when she pricked her finger. Yeah, sure, vox populi. But I was equally enthralled by such gracefully and authoritatively danced intelligence. During the Vision scene, Bourdon’s control and release and way of finishing each phrase now evoked memories of the way she had danced at her birthday party. Each act had you plunge deeper and deeper into all the facets and colors that are buried in a diamond.
Of course, Bourdon has one great advantage over the other two Auroras I saw: on-stage experience in the ballet. The last time this ballet was given in Paris was over a decade ago, so neither Battistoni nor McIntosh have had the luxury to start out as a little fairy, get the music and production into their bones and muscle memory, watch and learn from the stars while in the wings or milling about dressed for a mazurka. Stagecraft takes years.
Part of my reticence about the Beauties could be blamed on the hard-working and well-meaning Prince Desirés of both Thomas Docquir and Guillaume Diop. As most of the company’s male principals had decided to hang out over at the Palais Garnier and devote themselves to performing in Mats Ek’s Appartment rather than be involved in this run, basically there were few men left.
Both, as if they were relief pitchers, were scheduled to partner at least two if not three ballerinas. Where is the rehearsal time then to craft intimacy in dance and drama with your partner? Where is the time to work on your own role?
As I noted to myself during Act Two: “McIntosh seems better on her own and fills the space when she is the dream.” Act Three: “Fish dives with Docquir not thrilling. Steps executed, zero connection, she seems like a doll instead of a woman. Isn’t this supposed to be a wedding?”
Perhaps Thomas Docquir (March 11th and March 22nd) has simmered too long in secondary roles, including endless iterations of Rothbart, to be “the one.” He has clearly been working on refining his technique (solid from the start but now more polished, elastic, finessed, held up high) and elongating his lines. But, seriously, it is now time for Docquir to build up his self-confidence and stop avoiding the spotlight. When he came out on the stage in Act Two…both times few in the audience caught on that he was supposed to be the star. His Vision scene solo was made for some nice lines, yet the longing was missing. He didn’t ever challenge McIntosh to do that one percent more and when I next saw him with Bourdon my always accentuate-the-positive seatmate made an interesting comment. “If even he can’t believe that he is a prince, then why should she believe him? [pause] Then why should I?”
Guillaume Diop (Désiré)
Guillaume Diop (March 13th and April 3rd) is so talented and cheerfully radiant – and known — that even if he’s sometimes just a bit too all over the place (not only Etoile but in-demand fashion icon), the audience just takes to him before he even takes a second step. I saw him twice with Battistoni and clearly he learns fast and carries over new ideas from performance to performance. By the second performance I saw, the partnering between their had developed. Intense eye-contact led to easier connection.
He’s a very attentive partner – boy does he just know how to hold out his hand and whip his girl into pirouettes with concentrated nonchalance — and as a soloist he has impressive elevation and strength (those barrel turns). But he has got to keep working on refining his feet, still just a bit forgotten as they are too far away from his head, and he especially needed to re-ground his plié (I winced a few times on the 13th). While he knows how to stretch out of his balances, he’s begun to sit back on his standing leg and is not pulling up enough through his hip…a sign of being tired. He’s dancing too much and this worries me. Nevertheless, I am curious to how partnering a much more seasoned stage partner during the next run – Amandine Albisson — might galvanize him. Two young-uns is cute. Young talent rubbing up against stagecraft often results in more.
L’Isola Disabitata. Music by Joseph Haydn, staged by Simon Valastro. March 11-21, 2025, at the Amphithéatre, Opéra Bastille.
The Opéra Bastille has two little embedded and oft-forgotten venues, a frontal movie-theater-shaped Studio with about 240 seats and then an in-the-round Amphithéâtre that can hold about 500. The latter is where the performances took place – with a smaller audience because 22 members of the youthful Orchestre Ostinato (led by a bouncily enthusiastic François López-Ferrer) took up an entire section of the stadium seats. Good sound, juicy strings, and winds and woods that never burped or raspberried (a recurrent problem when the Paris Opéra’s orchestras deign to play for a ballet, alas).
The set is a craggy, lumpy, smooth in places, revolving (this will play into the scenario), rocky outcropping, with a baby orphan rock downstage right. An island on an island that all of the characters will use at some point to glide or slither around, slip or jump off of, hide or seek in a crevasse, or simply sigh while slumped on their bottoms below it. Shards of something litter the ground, but what? It can’t be bits of stone or wood chips, that would hurt the bare feet of all the characters, but polystyrene is too lightweight. Kudos to the inventive the scenographer, Lucie Mazières, for this stuff.
On March 21st, despite the spare and modern setting, you really could transport yourself back into the comparably intimate Haydnsaal at the Esterhazy Palace in Eisenstadt, just south of Vienna. Not only that, you could almost hear the elite from those days engaging in post-performance chatter about Enlightenment obsessions such as whether animals – or even women — have souls, the noble savage, nurture versus nature, and so on. I know that’s exactly what I overheard as we exited.
You could just feel that on one day Mozart must have latched onto this chamber opera for inspiration. Cosí looms on the horizon. Not only is one lead named Costanza [sic], but the whole thing is about how men and women never err in continuing to judge and misunderstand each other. As with Mozart, the happy ending will prove equally, and achingly, bittersweet.
Mozart himself surely had been enchanted to listen in on the final quartet. The young singers, most of them members of a project called L’Académie de l’Opéra national de Paris, gave proof of their acting and singing chops. More than that: Sofia Anisimova, Sima Ouahman, Luis-Felipe Sousa, Bergsvein Toverud, all moved about with easy, dancy, grace.
L’Isola Disabitata : Bergsvein Toverud, Sofia Anisimova, Nicolas Fayol, Sima Ouahman, Luis-Felipe Sousa.
The story feels as old as myth. Thirteen years ago, two sisters were abandoned on this godforsaken desert island by the older sister’s faithless new husband. Costanza has raised her very young sister to be so wary and distrustful of men that when she befriends a stag, she assumes that – since the animal is as wary of others as it is gentle – it must be a doe. (More about this later). Lo and behold, Gernando the faithless husband turns up on the shore with a friend after spending years in captivity. He was not faithless! He had in fact been captured by pirates one stupid day while Costanza was taking a nap on the beach around the corner. He’s spent years enslaved, yearning only to return to this abandoned island to either rescue his love or die upon her tomb. After many misunderstandings, two couples will be conjoined.
This mini-Odyssey has been staged by Simon Valastro, a former soloist of the Paris Opera Ballet. For many years, Valastro had been prized by the audience for his sensitive and acute theatricality. He had excelled in character parts, bringing heartbreaking vulnerability to melancholy/comedic roles such as the ridiculed Count de N in John Neumeier’s La Dame aux Camélias. [Just saying, he would have made for a marvelous Peruvian in Massine’s Gaïté Parisienne]. As stage director, Valastro proves that he is that kind of performing artist who can transmit his stagecraft to others, more of an enabler to talent than pompous sage. The singers clambered around that rock (and their conflicting emotions) with the kind of natural ease that can only be learned from a pro.
Because I sense that Valastro seems to be a stage director who leans into talent, I’m not sure what percentage of credit for the dancing by that Stag as Doe actually belongs to Valastro or to Nicolas Fayol, a sage of hip-hop. In the libretto, this creature was only supposed to be sung about by the younger sister rather than incarnated on stage. I’m glad, and I think Haydn would have been impressed, that Valastro decided to give a body to this fifth wheel. Fayol’s bio makes him sound like an equally untamable creature: born in the French version of the boonies, self-taught until age eighteen, all over the place, and, as he puts it, determined to remain free to define his situations and connections.
L’Isola Disabitata: Nicolas Fayol
It began galloping about even before the overture, oblivious to the spectators, making full use of an astonishingly flexible back and hamstrings. Coupled with a lack of affect. Fayol quickly convinced you that he had hooves, not hands. And that he was an animal with a soul: feral and docile in equal measure. He rolled, darted, flitted, and kept a wary distance from the singers, as his Pippi Longstocking Rasta antlers quivered. Early on, there is a moment where the ingenue younger sister Sylvia ( Sima Ouahman, as dynamic and assertive as a Dessay ) reaches out her hand to her deer and tries to pet him. Later on, she will stare in disbelief when her suitor, Enrico (Luis-Felipe Sousa, one of those baritones you just want to pack into your pocket and take home), tries to tame her in exactly the same way.
Sails rise and the big revolving rock begins to lift anchor. Calm seas and happy endings await.
In the end, the most moving moment was not even the harmonies of that final proto-Mozartian quartet. It was the sight of Nicolas Fayol’s faithful Hart, hunched and perched on the baby orphan rock, having been blithely forgotten and abandoned as the happy couples sail away, besotted by love. His body language reminded me of those awful videos you turn to when you can’t sleep — you know — the ones where you cannot believe that you actually watching a lone dog in a parking lot, crumpled in disbelief, as the only family he has ever known has just driven off.
A l’Opéra Bastille, L’Isola Disabitata : Cœurs brisés, Cœur de biche blessé
L’Isola Disabitata, musique de Joseph Haydn, mise en scène de Simon Valastro. 11-21 mars Amphithéâtre Olivier Messiaen. Opéra Bastille.
L’Opéra Bastille possède deux petites espaces intégrés et souvent oubliés ; une salle frontale pour les projections et les conférences de 240 places et un amphithéâtre en hémicycle qui peut accueillir autour de 500 spectateurs. Ce dernier est là où les représentations ont eu lieu avec un public plus restreint car les 22 membres du juvénile Orchestre Osinato, dirigé par l’enthousiaste et bondissant François Lopez-Ferrer, occupaient une section entière des gradins. Beau son, cordes savoureuses, ainsi que des vents et des bois qui jamais ne commettaient de couacs ou de canards, un problème récurrent de l’orchestre de l’Opéra lorsqu’il daigne jouer pour le ballet, hélas.
Le décor présente un affleurement, rocheux, escarpé, grumeleux, plus lisse par endroits, et tournant (cela aura son importance dans le scénario) ainsi qu’un mini caillou orphelin, posé devant côté jardin. Ce grand rocher est une sorte d’île dans l’île, que tous les personnages utiliseront pour glisser, se glisser, s’esquiver, en sauter, jouer à cache-cache dans une crevasse ou simplement soupirer affalés à ses pieds. Des tessons d’une matière non identifiée couvrent le sol. Cela ne peut être ni des graviers ni des copeaux de bois qui blesseraient les pieds nus des interprètes mais pas plus du polystyrène, trop léger. Bravo à l’inventive scénographe, Lucie Mazières, pour cette trouvaille.
Ce 21 mars, en dépit du décor dépouillé et moderne, vous pouviez vraiment vous transporter dans la comparablement intime Haydnsaal du palais Esterhazy d’Eisenstadt, au sud de Vienne. Non seulement cela, mais vous pouviez entendre l’élite de ce temps-là discourir après la représentation sur les obsessions des Lumières, à savoir si les animaux – ou les femmes – ont une âme, le bon sauvage, la nature versus la culture et ainsi de suite. Voilà exactement ce que j’ai entendu quand nous sommes sortis.
Vous pouviez imaginer qu’un jour Mozart s’était appliqué à exploiter cet opéra de chambre comme source d’inspiration. Cosí se dessine à l’horizon. Non seulement l’un des personnages principaux s’appelle Costanza (sic), mais tout tourne autour de comment hommes et femmes ne manquent jamais de se juger à tort ou de ne pas se comprendre. Comme chez Mozart, la fin heureuse s’avérera également, et douloureusement, douce-amère.
Mozart lui-même a dû être enchanté d’écouter secrètement le quatuor final. Les jeunes chanteurs, la plupart membres de l’Académie de l’Opéra national de Paris, ont donné la preuve de leur allant d’acteur et de chanteur. Bien mieux : Sofia Anisimova, Sima Ouahman, Luis-Felipe Sousa, Bergsvein Toverud se mouvaient tous avec une grâce aisée et dansante.
L’Isola Disabitata : Bergsvein Toverud, Sofia Anisimova, Nicolas Fayol, Sima Ouahman, Luis-Felipe Sousa.
L’histoire semble aussi vieille qu’un mythe. Treize années auparavant, deux sœurs ont été abandonnées sur cette île déserte paumée par le déloyal jeune mari de l’ainée des sœurs. Costanza a élevé sa très jeune sœur dans une telle méfiance et une telle suspicion des hommes que, s’étant liée d’amitié avec un cerf, elle croit que, puisque l’animal est aussi méfiant des autres que doux, il ne peut s’agir que d’une biche. (On en dira plus par la suite). Mais voilà que Germando, le mari déloyal, paraît sur le rivage en compagnie d’un ami après des années de captivité. Il n’était pas parjure ! Il avait en fait été capturé par des pirates un mauvais jour tandis que Costanza faisait un somme à quelques pas de là sur la plage. Il avait alors passé des années en captivité, aspirant uniquement à revenir sur cette île abandonnée soit pour sauver sa bien-aimée soit pour mourir sur sa tombe. Après bien des quiproquos, deux couples se conjoindront.
Cette mini odyssée a été mise en scène par Simon Valastro, un ancien sujet du ballet de l’Opéra de Paris. Des années durant, Valastro a été apprécié par le public pour son aiguë et sensible théâtralité. Il a excellé dans les rôles de caractère, apportant une poignante vulnérabilité à des rôles comico-mélancoliques tels que le ridicule comte N dans la Dame aux Camélias de John Neumeier [en passant, il aurait fait un merveilleux Péruvien dans le Gaité Parisienne de Massine]. En tant que metteur en scène, Valastro prouve qu’il est de ce genre d’artiste de scène qui sait transmettre ses qualités d’interprète aux autres, plus en tant que facilitateur qu’en tant que sage pompeux. Les chanteurs gravissaient le rocher (ainsi que leurs émotions contradictoires) avec une aisance qui n’a été acquise qu’auprès d’un professionnel.
Parce qu’il me semble que Valastro est un metteur en scène qui s’appuie sur le talent de ses interprètes, je ne suis pas certaine de quel pourcentage de paternité pour la partie dansée du cerf supposé biche revient à Valastro ou à Nicolas Fayol, sage du hip hop. Dans le livret, cette créature était seulement supposée être évoquée par le chant de la jeune sœur. Je suis heureuse, et je pense qu’Haydn aurait été impressionné, de la décision de Valastro de donner un corps à cette cinquième roue du carrosse. La biographie de Fayol le fait d’ailleurs paraître une créature tout aussi indomptable que le personnage qu’il dépeint : né dans l’équivalent français des « boonies », autodidacte jusqu’à ses dix-huit ans, touche à tout et, selon ses dires, déterminé à garder sa liberté afin de définir ses choix artistiques.
L’Isola DIsabitata: Nicolas Fayol.
Alors qu’il galopait en tous sens avant et durant l’ouverture, utilisant à plein son dos et ses tendons extraordinairement flexibles couplés à une totale absence d’affect, Fayol vous convainquait qu’il avait des sabots et non des mains, qu’il était un animal doté d’une âme, sauvage et docile à part égale. Il se roulait, dardait, voltigeait et se gardait à distance des chanteurs, tandis que frémissaient ses couettes- bois d’une Fifi Brindacier rasta. À un moment l’ingénue sœur cadette Sylvia (Sima Ouahman, aussi dynamique et assurée qu’une Dessay) tend la main vers son chevreuil et essaye de le caresser. Plus tard, elle se pétrifiera, incrédule, lorsque son prétendant, Enrico (Luis-Felipe Sousa, un de ces barytons que vous voudriez ramener à la maison), essaye de l’amadouer exactement de la même manière.
Le grand rocher tournant commence à hisser la voile et lever l’ancre. La mer est calme et le bonheur n’attend pas.
À la fin, le moment le plus émouvant n’était pourtant pas tant dans les harmonies du quatuor proto-mozartien. C’était la vue de Nicolas Fayol, cerf fidèle au cœur de biche, hissé et perché sur le bébé rocher orphelin, allègrement oublié et abandonné par les heureux couples qui s’embarquent au loin, rendus inconscients et stupides par l’Amour. Son langage corporel m’a rappelé ces affreuses vidéos qui défilent sur votre écran quand vous ne pouvez pas dormir – vous savez ! – celles ou vous ne pouvez croire que vous êtes en train de regarder un chien sur un parking d’autoroute, recroquevillé, incrédule, alors que la seule famille qu’il ait jamais connu vient de démarrer sans lui.
Libre traduction Cléopold
Commentaires fermés sur Opera Bastille, l’Isola Disabitata : Broken Hearts, Broken Hart
What would it have looked like in the end if Giselle’s heart had not been broken, Albrecht had forgotten about Bathilde in two seconds flat, and they lived happily ever after? Their names would be Valentine Colasante and Guillaume Diop. Their courtship would be bathed in sunshine from beginning to end.
What would it look have looked like if Swanhilda had been kidnapped by campy gypsies? She would have gotten her desired Franz in the end by hook or by crook, and the two of them would be called Léonore Baulac and Marc Moreau. A rainbow would smile upon them.
Paquita. December 17th (Valentine Colasante, Guillaume Diop, Pablo Legasa). Curtain call.
On December 17th, the light and unpretentious manner of Colasante’s Paquita made the audience root for her from start to finish. But to me, she seemed a bit…tame (for lack of a better word). This girl would either be saved by a prince charming, or not. Diop’s youthfully eager hero made his “blink and I’m done” attraction to her quite clear. And Colasante’s Paquita seemed to fluff up every time she was around him. He’s a very nice guy and a caring partner, an Albrecht with no secret story.
Diop kind of overdid it in his first solo, trying to impress his partner, as if he had been coached by Nicolas Le Riche for better or for worse. What I mean is that Le Riche had glorious talent and a penchant for rousing the audience with his split leaps even if that meant sacrificing precision. You might have seen a few off-finishes, a right leg that turned in too early before marvelous leaps and, much less visibly, “my toes aren’t completely stretched right now.” But the audience clearly did not care for such picky details. He got it all back into control as the evening went on. This very young étoile will hopefully use Manuel Legris as his model instead from now on: he’s got the talent to be the kind of star who never sacrifices precision for expression nor the other way around and still delights an audience.
For me, I wonder whether Valentine Colasante could make more of a contrast between 1) the 1840’s-ish first act of mime and terre à terre caressing of the floor by the foot (the realm of Carlotta Grisi, the first Paquita as well as the first Giselle) and 2) the full-out Petipa of the second act. She could have used really broken-in and more tapered toe shoes at first before later switching to those shiny modern ones when really needed. I wonder if her coach didn’t somehow convince this lovely ballerina, who makes dancing seem as natural as breathing, to dance “small and controlled.”
At some point I could not stop thinking about how everything had been so correct and well-rehearsed and pretty for hours now that maybe a bit of acceleration and deceleration of the phrasings would be welcome. All the partnering had been perfectly worked out and Diop did a great job on making the lifts work. But why was I actually thinking about the technique of partnering as I was watching, rather than swept away?
By the last act I was “OK, whatever, I’m not having a bad time. Maybe clean and pearly is just fine. Maybe rehearse it hard and just do it is all you need?” Their lines really matched, elegantly classical and not flashy. The audience around me was barely breathing, completely entranced by some kind of fairy magic. For me the last travelled lines in the last big pas could have travelled more, but did anyone around care other than me? No.
A night later the “feel” was very different, but why feel you need to choose between apples and oranges or sunshine and a rainbow?
*
* *
Whereas Valentine Colasante had shaped a Paquita gently doubtful but confused and insecure about her origins, Baulac’s Paquita was “nope, I know this is not right. I’m better than all of this. Hm. Maybe I can start getting attention by just swishing my skirt.” Her Swanhilda, cheerily resourceful from the get-go, helped give the limp narrative a bit more of a dramatic arc than it normally has. In Scene Two at the tavern, Baulac was definitely trying to save her Franz from losing his life to bad wine, and was way more focused on making the most out of the opportunities for slapstick. No damsel in distress, this one.
Instead of a ready, willing, and able youth, Marc Moreau, as soon as he appeared onstage, defined space around himself as a perfectly poised Lucien d’Hervilly , a gentleman in no way boyish but definitely open to adventure. His technique was precise, but he didn’t forget about the big picture either.
In Léonore Baulac’s radiant Paquita, there was no way that Marc Moreau was going to find a Giselle. Perhaps a little adventure might happen in the woods with a naughty sylph, very flirty and strong-willed from the start? Nope, not that either. This man had no chance of getting away, and he didn’t mind at all. Moreau and Baulac’s lifts felt more naturally floated and less “rehearsed” than the night past. Everything felt more reactive than activated. At one point, he slid his hand gently down her arm from her shoulder to her wrist before a turn. Yesterday that same moment had been “I’ve got the wrist, let’s go.” During the last act, I began to fantasize about seeing Baulac and Moreau dance an iridescent and inflected Theme and Variations.
Paquita, December 18th (Léonore Baulac, Marc Moreau, Pablo Legasa). Curtain call.
*
* *
What’s so weird about Pierre Lacotte’s reinvention of Paquita is that despite its numerous dramaturgical faults, it works for the audience. And this big ball of fluff actually works much better now that it is housed at the Opera Bastille. As opposed to the tight box that is the Palais Garnier’s stage, here all the endless group dances (from the waltzes to the children’s polonaise) do in fact get space to breathe and be danced big…albeit not always with the music and often messily aligned.
However, a breath of air does not excuse the other weaknesses that this yet another Pierre Lacotte staging of yet another 19th century ballet always had in the first place. The plot summary provided in the fat program (save your money and just invent your own plot) will never rhyme or reason with what you see on stage. And, frankly, certain aspects of the plot have gotten even fuzzier due to a bigger venue with more distant sightlines.
Who on earth can tell that the evil governor’s much more youthful daughter (as we see it) in fact happens to be his sister (not to mention that we are often unsure whether he wants Lucien killed or Paquita). I’d always thought Bathilde in Giselle was kind of a loser role, but Dona Serafina? She appears, dances a little, sits down stage left and then just fades from view until curtain. Both Nais Dubosq (a bit of a wallflower on the 17th ) and Fanny Gorse (more assertive on the 18th if that is humanly possible) tried to give this impoverished role a bit of visibility.
And then this: from nowhere in the house now – OK, maybe from the front row — can you now even begin to decipher what is written on that “marble slab” in Act One ? But the worst part is that, due to sitting even further away than normal at the Opera Bastille, “the locket,” [our heroine’s “get out of jail free” card] becomes even more spectacularly illegible, too. Why couldn’t repeated locket pantomime have been a priority in Lacotte’s eye? Maybe give the little thing a Giselle/Bathilde kind of big awkward necklace visibility? Instead, the “key to the mystery” is pinned to the dancer’s skirt in a way that cannot be seen. Perhaps the hip level location is historically correct. But I bet the pendant was bigger, maybe against a darker skirt, and its original theft accompanied by mime of a more semaphoric variety. It’s now been just about two decades that I’ve watched Lacotte’s reconstruction of this “lost ballet.” Only once did I actually notice Inigo steal the locket in the first place. This needs to be seen, maybe à la Basilio stealing the innkeeper’s money bag. The dancer’s fault? No. Lacotte should have made a lot of the panto way bigger.
On both nights, Pablo Legasa was wasted as the manipulative Inigo. Like Audric Bezard once was, he’s getting stuck in character roles when he’s really a danseur noble. Legasa’s acting responds to his ballerina, he’s just not a ham. So it was logical that he was no macho gypsy king on either night. With the gentle Colasante, he was Berthe, worried about a daughter who dances too much. When facing off with a tricksy Baulac, Legasa morphed into a hapless Doctor Coppelius, naturally.
Speaking of Coppelia. Why doesn’t the company perform one of the greatest ballets ever created for it? Why are reconstructed first acts buried in a vault at the school, only to be exhumed for the Paris public maybe once about every fifteen years? And why, instead of letting Lacotte dig himself a deep hole with his swan song – the dreadful Le Rouge et le Noir – hadn’t management simply asked him to come in and toss off an act three?
Gluck’s Sémiramis/Don Juan. Ballet du Capitole. October 26th and 27th, 2024.
I once sat next to an annoying frat boy at an Upper East Side dinner party who thought a clever conversation starter was “I adore Berlioz. What kind of music do you like?” I sighed. “Oh, anything that I feel I could dance to, so I’m not into Berlioz.” Eyebrows pointed in alarm, he sneered, “so you like disco?!” and then talked to other people for the rest of the night. OK, I still do have fond memories of dancing like a demon to disco. But I with hindsight I realize what else I could have said: “I’m into dance, yes, but most of all I love it when I can watch bodies find a story and their own truth in music.”
*
* *
Settled back in my seat in Toulouse in October, that long forgotten exchange popped up while I listened to Jordi Savall conduct the dance suite from Christoph Willibald Glück’s Iphigenia. The audience is treated to an extended overture before even one dancer will set a foot on the stage. As the straight-backed and craggy Savall elegantly led his brilliantly cheery Orchestre Le Concert des Nations into the final rousing chaconne, I definitely felt I had heard a story displayed through music. I felt like dancing.
I was really intitrigued by the fact that what followed would be re-imaginings of the first ever story ballets, revisited. Of course the choreographies have been lost, but here you would have authentic 18th century scores, neither intended as intermezzi in a larger opera (think Les Indes galantes, for example) nor bits of hit songs squished together in the typical patchwork ballet scores of that time (think Ivo Kramer’s subtly re-invented La Fille mal gardée, in the Ballet du Capitole’s repertoire/archives). In its time, “real” music for a ballet was revolutionary. Can this music still make us feel?
Sémiramis
Ballet du Capitole de Toulouse. Programme Gluck. Photographie David Herrero.
Ángel Rodriguez’s ballet to the music for Glück’s ballet Sémiramis followed apace. As there was no plot summary in the program, odd, hummm, I’d read up about the original play by Voltaire and was ready for anything…except to be served up something rather abstract. A divertissement, after all that?
Of course, silly, I don’t think I would have wanted to witness a dancing Semiramis waving around a vial of poison or being stabbed to death in slow-motion mime either, but here we ended up from the start back to the plotless dance interlude. Rodriguez’s piece, albeit a quite skilful and visually absorbing “divertissement,” was exactly the genre that Glück and the long-forgotten choreographer Gaspare Angiolini were trying to get away from in the first place.
We start – in silence, odd, as we have a lot of Glück to get through– with a giant lump/tumulus center stage that begins to winkle out some women.
The lump turns out to be a mass of iridescent fabric that will spend its time slowly spooling itself up to the rafters (until its inevitable swoosh back down in order recreate the tumulus from before).
The women squeak like birds as they rise up from the lump as if lofted by strings. They wiggle arms and waggle fingers, rise and swoon, swoop and then bend their knees, trace some kind of semaphoric language in the air. Later they will form circles. Men next emerge from the fabric lump. The music does start at some point and from then on these seven men and seven women continue to spiral around each other, touch and go, bodies hang off bodies and are carefully placed back on the ground in various configurations. There’s a duet for two who cup their hands for some reason.
Ballet du Capitole de Toulouse. Programme Gluck. Sémiramis. Kayo Nakazato & Jeremy Leydier. Photographie David Herrero.
The lifts are almost always horizontal, with bent knees and flexed feet, gently Kylian in feeling. At some point, random lone women successively meander straight across the back of the stage just in front of the ever-rising backcloth. This visual distraction was not the best of ideas because: at just about the same moment during both matinees my eyes hooked onto the cloth (ooh it’s gone from gold to blue!) and my mind drifted towards memories of those poignant moments when Thierry Malandain takes fabric and makes it a real partner in the story.
Even if I found my mind channelling too many other choreographers who do all this better, I can’t say I was bored. Sémiramis was pleasantly soothing. The dancers were utterly committed (and in the case of Philippe Solano, explosive). But by the time we got to the troupe all running forward in slow motion — oh Lord, that gimmick — I felt a bit stuck.
Ballet du Capitole de Toulouse. Programme Gluck. Philippe Solano. Photographie David Herrero.
Much later, I ran across a really touching text by Ángel Rodríguez in the Capitole’s magazine. The choreographer dedicates this piece to his mother and all the other women who hold up at least half of the sky. Did I see happening onstage? Not really. But it’s a lovely idea.
*
* *
Don Juan
Ballet du Capitole de Toulouse. Programme Gluck. Photographie David Herrero.
Edward Clug found a better balance between plot and abstraction in his Don Juan. As Molière is mother’s milk to the French – everybody here is forced to study his plays in high school – light references were all this audience needed in order to situate themselves in the goings on.
Could this piece travel outside of France? Most possibly: the tragedy of Semiramis is niche. The Latin Lover, for better or worse, is a universal cliché.
We begin and end with the vivid image of the dancers hovering (glowering?) in a semi-circle around a man on the ground in an upside-down Christ pose, only to smother and then extract him from a mosh pit of arms and legs. In this piece, too, arms and knees get bent, feet get flexed, but here all these limbs serve to push the idea of a story into the foreground.
The set and props by Marko Japelj, and costumes by Leo Kulas, are minimal yet perfectly evocative. Moveable semi-transparent dark partitions pierced by Neo-Mauresque arabesques were wheeled around to create spaces you could recognize (a convent, a secluded garden, the dinner party). A giant “stone” horse gets rolled in to advance the action, along with a stiff red skirt that was inhabited and incarnated in multiple and specifically recognisable ways.
Ballet du Capitole de Toulouse. Programme Gluck. Photographie David Herrero.
Yes, this is very hard to describe, but it works.
During the October 26th Saturday matinee, Alexandre De Oliveira Ferreira’s Don was a peacock from the start, emerging from the puddle with flounce and go, ready for the sighs and air kisses that were his due: a cheery Teflon Narcissus, chillingly incapable of feelings or regrets right down to the moment he meets his sorry end. On Sunday, Ramiro Gómez Samón’s shaped a more sensual, sexually-ambiguous, and more ambivalent Don. His interpretation proved perhaps more compelling and seductive, to me.
On Saturday, Marlen Fuerte Castro’s Donna Elvira was implacable and forceful from start to stop. She seemed to incarnate The Commander (whom we never see) more than his confused child. To me, Solène Monnereau’s alternately soft and sharp and more womanly Elvira seemed more true to Molière (and later Da Ponte): she used her body to trace a theatrical (albeit abstracted) arc from confused woman in love, to woman disappointed in love, to Fury bent upon revenge.
Ballet du Capitole de Toulouse. Programme Gluck. Kleber Rebello et Solène Monnereau. Photographie David Herrero.
My only real quibble is the lack of “screen time” devoted to that trope – the scheming lovable rascal who speaks power to power (or at least to the audience) – the manservant Sganarelle (Leporello to some of you). He’s the audience’s ally. Dinner party trash-talking Don Juans may seem handsome at first but, boy, those Sganarelle-types always turn out to be so much more fun once you get them out there on the dance floor.
Don Juan. Philippe Solano (Sganarelle). Photographie David Herrero
Philippe Solano’s version of Sganarelle – a speedy, elastic, and sarcastic presence — had the snarky wit of a court jester. Kleber Rebello a day later, differently delicate and perhaps even more sarcastic, also spoke to me. What a pity the choreographer did not think to give them the last word. Both times, when it was all over, during the happy (and deserved) applause, my mind flew back to the way Paul Taylor gives his “little girl” a pause and a sweeping arms-out bow at the very end of Esplanade, a moment that the dancer can choose to execute either with reverence or with sass. I would have loved have seen that done here.
If you are in Barcelona in March, or Paris in May, snap up tickets to see the Ballet du Capitole dance to the music of a fabulous tiny orchestra. You won’t regret it, and may even find you may feel like dancing. Why not ?
Commentaires fermés sur In Toulouse : Does Gluck Make Me Feel Like Dancing ?