Why on earth did we get so many tickets to this thing? After being stuck in a room endlessly watching endless rehearsals for La Bayadère on the phone during Covid, what did we get when the theaters reopened? More Baya. And now it’s back to Baya. I arrived at my first performance in a state of advanced gloom.
But during the overture I perked up. To my delight, for once the musicians in the pit had decided to take “ballet music” seriously and behave. Without the usual cringe-inducing woops and boops and jam-ups, Minkus sounded like real music. Koen Kessels’s reactive conducting made it evident for once that if someone was off the beat you knew whom to blame. This series was going to be bearable after all.
********
************
June 17th: An Enchanted Flute
Léonore Baulac’s poignant Nikiya immediately enveloped herself in the music. Dare I call her a dancing flute? A tuning fork? Sound and emotion shiver through her body and find release through her arms. She is melancholy, wistful, bust carefully placed forward … Giselle in Act II. Viscerally disgusted and shaken by the Grand Brahmin’s overtures, with Solor her back suddenly opened up and her arms grew even longer. This Nikiya believes completely in her handsome savior. When her hero swears his faith upon the pyre, she is clearly convinced, like Giselle, that true love lasts forever.
Léonore Baulac is at that “sweet spot” in her career where physical ability and artistry coincide. This allows her to take her roles to another level. Baulac’s Nikiya reacts with seemingly unrehearsed spontaneity to every situation she encounters.
In the Confrontation Scene — as with her Judith in Pina Bausch’s Bluebeard — she became increasingly like a small defenseless animal in pain, biting back as best as she could with tiny sharp teeth. In Act II, as Baulac began her fraught lament, I had the weird impression that she had lost weight during intermission. Emotions flickered, flowed, and intensified in cadence to the music. In Act III, our heroine seemed completely weightless, a gentle breeze. The way she held back a microsecond then echoed and amplified Solor’s movements made it clear that she was a delicate figment of his opium-induced dreams.
The best actors don’t “act,” they listen. Alas, given the rest of this cast on the 17th, Baulac could only rely upon the orchestra for support and release. Let’s face it, the much-maligned Minkus knew how to cue emotional verismo. This Nikiya, as graceful and fragile as a glass figurine, was stuck a world of tin soldiers.
Paul Marque had first jetéd in with soft, even languorous, authority. He knows how to make his grand leaps hover up there. His pantomime discussion with Daniel Stokes’s twitchy Fakir was clear and slow. But this gravitas evaporated the moment he returned to dancing. A kind of gritty determination – especially in pirouettes – more suited to a competition, took over. This continued to be a problem. He acted out surprise and unease at his forced marriage but then seemed to forget all about it during the Grand Pas. He’s been dancing a lot. Exhaustion plus adrenalin? In Act III he continued to interpret rushing as a kind of default mode for expressing despair.
As Gamzatti, Bluenn Battistoni continues to rely upon her technical finesse but, as an Étoile, she really needs to start working on her projection. Maybe I shouldn’t say this, but I’ve seen her now how many times yet have trouble recalling her face, identifying a persona. Is it her coach? Does she need contacts? Is it stage-fright? But ever since her Beauty a year ago, she only seems to begin to start to glow during a third act. And then she’s just lovely. The problem is that Gamzatti doesn’t have a third act… Battistoni’s Wedding Pas had an uneven feel. During the adagio she seemed coolly triumphant in a Black Swanny way but then disappeared into a very careful, hemmed-in variation that didn’t take advantage of the massive space on stage. Everything got tighter from pirouettes to arabesques, nothing stretched nor reached. Her Italian into regular fouetté’s were strong and perfect in the wrong way: she cranked them out with a kind of scary force.
********
************
June 29th: The Violin’s Plaint
Dorothée Gilbert. The audience, of course, exploded when she made her entrance.
Her Nikiya reminded me more of an Odette than a Giselle, cooler and warier than Baulac. I really did wonder whether this Nikiya hadn’t once been a real princess who had gotten trapped in a temple dancer’s body due to some evil spell or reincarnation gone wrong. She was damsel in distress, certainly, but wise beyond her years and neither vulnerable nor naïve. Just one sharp suspicious glance – plus a regal “you high caste, me not” snippet of pantomime – made the Grand Brahmin (Yann Chailloux, very King and I) wither. Gilbert’s distinctive face has long reminded me of that of the young Joan Crawford in her early days on screen. Like the actress, Gilbert radiates an inner strength and calm assurance, but beneath that façade wounds can plunge in deep.
Gilbert’s Nikiya throbbed more to the sound of plucked strings than to the call of the flute. Her sense of gravity is more vertical than Baulac’s: hers is a spine that refuses to bend just because the winds say so.
Hugo Marchand’s Solor started out as a flirtatious and playful suitor, an Albrecht confident that everything always ends well.
Gilbert sang quiet duets with her partner of long standing. They’ve had a much commented-upon alchemy since the beginning of their pairing. He can literally tell where she is even with his back turned to her, which made Act III even more compelling. Fans of G/M don’t kill me, but I found one flaw in this performance: it’s very uncommon for Gilbert to search for her balances. She seemed to be unable to release some tension in her shoulders which, through osmosis, spread to her partner.
Roxane Stojanov’s Gamzatti – no Black Swan, but an entitled Bathilde who expects protocol be followed — put a full stop to this romance. An Albrecht instead of a warrior, Marchand was much more visibly discomfited by the princess than Paul Marque had been on June 17th. You really saw him try to rebel against the Rajah’s dictates as he lurked and peeped from behind corners while trying to figure out what to do. When Act II took off, Stojanov’s Gamzatti knew she’d won and led all the way through the pas de deux with sovereign ease, not force. Marchand reacted progressively to his beloved’s pain in a way the other Solor visibly hadn’t. At one point, “I want to sink into a hole in the ground” was quite readable.
Act III allowed us to bask in Gilbertmarchand’s aura. We had the same soloists for the variations both nights and my impressions were mixed. Hohuyn Kang is usually a dance-y dancer. Like so many who have been cast in the First variation for years now, Kang needs to be told this simple fact: you just don’t need to lift that side leg up so high in the sissonne/developé/assemblé. This displaces your center, disrupts the flow of the combination, makes the music sound clunky, and, frankly, ruins the overall line. Inès McIntosh’s second variation impressed the audience with her combination of technical maestra and naturally shaped lines. Everything was luminous, nothing was overdone. That’s just the way she always dances. As Number 3, the talented Bianca Scudamore gave a surprisingly unmusical, even heavy, interpretation that progressed nowhere. No build-up, no humorous response to the the oom-pah-pah heft of the score. Scudamore is scheduled to dance Gamzatti when I go on July 8th. Let’s see what happens.
********
************
July 3rd: A Muted Harp
I was, alas, bewildered and disappointed by Heloïse Bourdon’s Nikiya on July 3rd. The elegant simplicity and easy control of her dance remains evident, but here somehow the character seemed to elude her. More the pity because Germain Louvet’s impeccable and feverishly eager Solor did bring something out of her in Act 1, a kind of complicit, gleeful, bodily confidence that then vanished again once she got back to work as a devadasi. I had the feeling she been coached to a such a deep point of interiority that her Nikiya became mainly inscrutable. I held out hope when the Kingdom of the Shades began: Bourdon seemed to remember being alive, she followed the sound of the harp, her calls to Louvet with her arms were so warm that his Solor could only follow. Then, boom, for the rest of the act, the gentle ghost vanished, replaced by some kind of zombie. Literally expressionless, yet dominant, as if trying to wipe out their story rather than preserve it.
Bourdon had been, however, toweringly ferocious when she refused to be pushed around by Gamzatti è tutti quanti. You could see emotional pain running down Bourdon’s spine as her body reached out to tell her story during Act II. “How can you forget us so fast, Solor?” Aha, I thought, so this is why Myrtha’s is still so pissed off after almost two centuries. Have you ever wondered about the Queen of the Wilis’s backstory? Well, here you have it.
And who wouldn’t be infuriated by Clara Mousseigne’s simpering Gamzatti? A princess? Nah. Louvet/Solor’s deftly acted slow burn of realization that this Bathilde 2.0 turns out to be just an empty shell in good clothes made you hope he’d go off script, grab that snake, and shove it down her bodice.
Mousseigne has always danced with efficiency but without a drop of that generosity, lift, or distilled feminine elegance is the very definition of a ballerina. Her extensions don’t extend beyond her toes. Her double attitude turns that finish in arabesque plié, for example, didn’t thrill precisely because she seemed to be saying “I control this and make the music – and everybody — wait for me.” She knows exactly how to fouetté for maximum applause. She can show off but clearly does not use her body to serve the persona that is embedded in the music. She flaps her hands instead.
My antipathy for this dancer would be reconfirmed by her variation as the First Shade on July 8. A mechanical doll with a tin ear? Worse, she was the only Shade who smiled all the way through Act III. Isn’t it great to be dead?
********
************
July 8th: Encore
Léonore Baulac again, but with a new lover and a new nemesis.
Guillaume Diop soars in, more connected to his feet than I’d seen lately. He demonstrates a new kind of maturity and adult manliness. Rubens Simon’s rabbity Fakir doesn’t overdo the “yes, massa” stuff and shows a bit of stage intelligence: just why were all the other Fakirs clapping so hard when the whole point is not to wake up the Grand Brahmin?
Baulac and Diop fit well together. Their lines and rhythms, their sense of call and response, match. Indeed, both unfurl their arms with the same soft inflections. Their arms together reminded me of tendrils or the lianas in the set design. This gave their partnering a delicious Art Nouveau look. This pliant couple is not in the throes of passion but in the giddy bliss of innocent love.
As an actress, Bianca Scudamore was most believable as Gamzatti. When this sheltered princess realizes that there is something called “a rival,” her astonishment feels real, intense, and not overcooked. Indeed, these three made you feel that they were all equally naïve.
The way Scudamore crafted her character’s emotional arc from perplexed surprise into viperine fury was positively operatic. She offered Baulac, the most reactive of acting dancers, a real sparring partner. You could almost hear high notes. If someone ever concocts “Aida: The Ballet,” Scudamore would be my first choice for Amneris.
In the Grand Pas, Scudamore put on a cat that swallowed the canary face and led the dance. I chuckled when she gripped Diop’s hands and sharply pulled him closer, already a wife who insists upon proprieties in public. Her dance was strong and precise, if sometimes a bit earthbound. She smoothed over a few moments of not really being in tune with the music and roused the audience with plenty of double fouettés.
Of all the Gamzatti’s, Scudamore’s stayed the most reactive while seated to the side during Nikiya’s big moment, growing increasingly wistful as Diop’s Solor kept avoiding her gaze. In the original Giselle, Bathilde shows up in the forest to take a devastated Albrecht back home to the castle. I could see this Gamzatti doing just that.
Meanwhile, I haven’t mentioned the Golden Idols. Antoine Kirscher’s on June 17th and July 3 were, how to most kindly to describe it, lopsided and clenched. Thomas Doquir’s tight arabesque and heavy reliance on the beat limited his more solid, but overly careful, version on the 29th. But on this night, Andrea Sarri – alternately sharp and smooth, hieratic and almost human – reminded us that he is supposed to be a metal statuette brought to life by music.
On the 3rd and 8th of July, Act III also provided other casts for the variations. In the first, Camille Bon on the 3rd did find the right balance and avoided the trap of that raised leg. Her developés unfolded as, and into, part of a larger sense of movement. Saki Kuwabara’s second variation on the 3rd, brisk and fluid, holds up when compared to Marine Ganio’s on the 8th. I don’t know how many times I’ve seen Ganio in this variation, but you can never tire of her creamy precision. Her dance is like a string of pearls. I was immensely lucky to see Nine Seropian twice as the Third Shade. A dancer with fine musical and theatrical intelligence, she clearly understood that this is a waltz, and that a waltz is not “one-two-three-wait” but “one-two-three-aaand.” Let me put it this way: I’ve had more than enough of La Bayadère for now, but the day either Seropian or Ganio gets cast as one of the leads, I’ll be ready for more..
Cléopold
Fenella
Giselle (Adam, Coralli/Perrot/Bart-Poliakov), Ballet de l’Opéra de Paris. Représentation du 17/10 (Hannah O’Neill, Reece Clarke, Héloïse Bourdon).
Stagecraft
Cette saison, l’Opéra fait rentrer à son répertoire un ballet à éclipses pourtant né entre ses murs. Sylvia, premier ballet créé pour le cadre du Palais Garnier, a connu en effet moult versions et a disparu maintes fois du répertoire.
Les Balletonautes 